Thursday, February 28, 2008

Skateboard meets Hot Coffee

Last Thursday as I was about to start the class, our classmate Doug walked pass me to the rear of the room carrying his skateboard, and just as I was uttering the phrase “sexual fluidity,” he apparently—I say “apparently” because I missed the actual mishap—hit a coffee cup on Erica’s chair and caused the hot drink to spill on her. They both coped gracefully with the minor though painful an embarrassing disaster. Doug helped with the cleaning and Erica bravely left class and returned a while afterward wearing different pants and acting as correctly and exemplarily as she always does in being one of the very best students I know.
The incident (or should I say accident?) made me think about the role of chance in humor and the different styles of recording or filming a sudden occurrence. In the age of You Tube, a video of the mishap would most likely cause asinine laughter. Voices and sounds in the video would lack proper immediacy and the framed visual scope would bleed the scene of emotional depth and dramatic texture.
You Tube has expanded a million-fold the on-the-spot opportunistic viewing that fifty years ago was made popular on TV by Candid Camera. The staged or set-up element in Candid Camera would have transformed the accident last Thursday into a faked incident employing Doug as bait to see how Erica reacted as accidental victim—or using her as a trap to see how he acted as the accident’s innocent trigger.
From the point of view of audiovisual representation the event can be framed in either one of these two genres: the true accident caught on video, or the faked accident staged for people to laugh at the expense of someone who is caught in a web of “candid” deceit.
But suppose we filmed the incident as a scene from a screenplay. Doug and Erica could play themselves or play two people like themselves or different from themselves. Our film would be a romantic comedy. A guy who goes around on a skateboard and a girl who is a surfer, a swimmer, perhaps a snowboarder, collide. (I’ll let you write the rest of the script).
Another “filmic” possibility exists which would take us back to the machine element in humans considered in the class where I showed clips from Steven Spielberg 1941. The film perspective in this case would be avant-garde, in the specific sense in which human actions and motives are dehumanized and people are seen not as individuals but as tokens of forces outside themselves and coordinated not by the will of God or human agency but by pure chance. In this other film I play the professor (sane or insane) whose words serve as the comic frame for the incident. Just as I am saying “sexual fluidity” (in reference to a new Harvard book by psychology professor Lisa Diamond) two students “create” or “stage” or “generate” an “accident” scene in which my reference to “fluidity” in women’s “sexual” attitudes is by sheer coincidence “quoted” or “echoed” in the incident in which a male student knocks a cup that spills hot coffee on a female student, and so on.
My purpose in writing this is to make you think about the role of “contingency” or chance as opposed to “determination” and control or design in how small or focal events may be integrated into different kinds of plots within different genres of visual and film representations.

No comments: