Thursday, February 28, 2008

Skateboard meets Hot Coffee

Last Thursday as I was about to start the class, our classmate Doug walked pass me to the rear of the room carrying his skateboard, and just as I was uttering the phrase “sexual fluidity,” he apparently—I say “apparently” because I missed the actual mishap—hit a coffee cup on Erica’s chair and caused the hot drink to spill on her. They both coped gracefully with the minor though painful an embarrassing disaster. Doug helped with the cleaning and Erica bravely left class and returned a while afterward wearing different pants and acting as correctly and exemplarily as she always does in being one of the very best students I know.
The incident (or should I say accident?) made me think about the role of chance in humor and the different styles of recording or filming a sudden occurrence. In the age of You Tube, a video of the mishap would most likely cause asinine laughter. Voices and sounds in the video would lack proper immediacy and the framed visual scope would bleed the scene of emotional depth and dramatic texture.
You Tube has expanded a million-fold the on-the-spot opportunistic viewing that fifty years ago was made popular on TV by Candid Camera. The staged or set-up element in Candid Camera would have transformed the accident last Thursday into a faked incident employing Doug as bait to see how Erica reacted as accidental victim—or using her as a trap to see how he acted as the accident’s innocent trigger.
From the point of view of audiovisual representation the event can be framed in either one of these two genres: the true accident caught on video, or the faked accident staged for people to laugh at the expense of someone who is caught in a web of “candid” deceit.
But suppose we filmed the incident as a scene from a screenplay. Doug and Erica could play themselves or play two people like themselves or different from themselves. Our film would be a romantic comedy. A guy who goes around on a skateboard and a girl who is a surfer, a swimmer, perhaps a snowboarder, collide. (I’ll let you write the rest of the script).
Another “filmic” possibility exists which would take us back to the machine element in humans considered in the class where I showed clips from Steven Spielberg 1941. The film perspective in this case would be avant-garde, in the specific sense in which human actions and motives are dehumanized and people are seen not as individuals but as tokens of forces outside themselves and coordinated not by the will of God or human agency but by pure chance. In this other film I play the professor (sane or insane) whose words serve as the comic frame for the incident. Just as I am saying “sexual fluidity” (in reference to a new Harvard book by psychology professor Lisa Diamond) two students “create” or “stage” or “generate” an “accident” scene in which my reference to “fluidity” in women’s “sexual” attitudes is by sheer coincidence “quoted” or “echoed” in the incident in which a male student knocks a cup that spills hot coffee on a female student, and so on.
My purpose in writing this is to make you think about the role of “contingency” or chance as opposed to “determination” and control or design in how small or focal events may be integrated into different kinds of plots within different genres of visual and film representations.

Sunday, February 24, 2008

Rita, Eat your Hear Out

Natalie Portman

Emma Forrest
It’s so dull when the first line states that the star arrives wearing “not a scrap of make-up”. I could pretend that Natalie Portman had false eyelashes that fell into her tea and hot-pink lipstick smeared across her cheek as gawpers in this Santa Fe cafe turned to stare. And the great thing is, she’d probably play along.
I first interviewed Portman, in her home town of Long Island, when she was 16. Now, 10 years on, she is as sweet – and clear-faced – as I remember her. Back then, after the interview, we almost collapsed in K-Mart when we found promotional toothbrushes bearing her Star Wars image. Today, in Santa Fe, where she is shooting Jim Sheridan’s Brothers, we shop at Wholefoods for ingredients to make vegan cupcakes with the actors who play her and Tobey Maguire’s children. Yes, the girl who became a star in Leon, aged 12, is playing a mum. “I knew how to act like an adult from a really young age. I could turn it on and off. They’d say, ‘She doesn’t seem like a kid, she seems like an adult.’ Now, it kicks me in the butt, and people think, ‘She doesn’t seem like an adult, she seems like a kid.’ ”
Portman has close friends who are having kids now, such as the flame-haired actress Bryce Dallas Howard, who, when they were teens at summer camp, played Helena to her Hermia in A Midsummer Night’s Dream. Portman feels a while from motherhood herself, though she is in a serious relationship with Nathan Bogle, the British model and a founder of the Rag & Bone label, whom she politely refuses to talk about. She has consistently declined to talk about any beau, but does say that, as an only child, “I always want to be with someone who has siblings. I will never date another only child”. She pauses. “But I think I have dated exclusively first children.” Harvard, which she famously dropped out of Hollywood to attend, is “70% only and first children”, she says, “which makes sense. My career would not have happened if I had brothers or sisters. There’s no way my parents would have allowed one kid to be a star”.
Although quite a few films are now made in this artsy New Mexico town, Portman is the biggest thing to happen to Santa Fe in some time. To begin with, there’s that face – nose, eyebrows, cheekbones and chin of glass – paired with round, soulful eyes and the softest mouth. Because of that face, because of the slender lines of her body, she has the reputation for being the most elegant of young actresses, and, yes, she has a jade cashmere sweater, skinny blue jeans, a check coat that ties smartly at her tiny waist. But she’s also wearing big, green, deeply inelegant wellies, because she has found the cheaper a shoe is, the more likely it is to be vegan. Hence her launch of a shoe line for Te Casan, with all profits going to the Nature Conservancy.
“Basically, I did it out of a lack of choice. Stella McCartney does great shoes, but they’re expensive and very fashiony. I wanted a mary-jane shoe without leather. I’ve been getting stuff from Target, which is de facto vegan because it’s so cheap. But I did need some shoes that weren’t made of canvas or plastic.”
With values instilled by her American artist mother and Israeli doctor father, good deeds are par for the Portman course. Producing the first-ever iTunes charity album, she raised an enormous amount of money for the Foundation for International Community Assistance (Finca), which provides micro-financing for the world’s lowest-income entrepreneurs.
Last year, Portman went to Rwanda to make a documentary about endangered gorillas for the Discovery Channel. This year, she begins a deal with Participant Productions, the makers of Syriana, which has an ethical mandate to make films that promote social change. Her first movie as director will be an adaptation of A Tale of Love and Darkness, Amos Oz’s history of his family and Israel. The scope is vast, and Portman, who was born in Jerusalem, is glad she did six months of college there, if only because it brought back her Hebrew.
It’s hard to imagine that in 2002, she co-hosted a new-year party with Britney Spears. What on earth did the two have in common? “We both had the same first job. We both understudied for an off-Broadway musical called Ruthless. I never met her, but I took over from her when she left to join the Mickey Mouse Club. So we connected over that. She invited me to a few things and my guy friends at college said, ‘We have to go.’ I’m sad to see how everyone’s treating her now.”
Now that Britney’s star has fallen and she is mocked as coming from poor white trash, does Portman think there are also stabilising advantages in belonging to an ethnic minority?
“Absolutely. I identify very strongly as Jewish, but I could be Indian, Puerto Rican . . . Anything that gives you a cultural identity makes you know who you are and grounds you, even as a young girl trying on identities.” She sighs. “Any time I see something about Britney, I close it. I can’t look at it. I’m usually interested in gossip, but this makes my stomach hurt.”
She feels extremely lucky to have missed the worst of the paparazzi madness, with the videographers and bloggers. “I was allowed to establish myself when it wasn’t this crazy. I was going to high school and college and there were no paparazzi after me. But that was only five years ago. It wouldn’t happen now.”
One such piece of tabloid bait is Scarlett Johansson, with whom Portman shares the screen in The Other Boleyn Girl. They play sisters in a love triangle with Henry VIII. “It’s a catfight movie.” Highbrow catfighting? “Not really highbrow,” she laughs. “Have you read the book?”
She catches herself, then does her best to think her way into promoting a movie that is getting mixed reviews. “These two sisters love each other so much, and are made out to be rivals by the values of society that uses women as pawns.”
She doesn’t want us to think the film fosters rivalry between women. “I hate that – it drives me crazy. The truth is, it’s hard to find a really great girl, but when you find one, it’s the best. The vast majority of my friends are guys, but the ones I talk to about everything are my girls.”
Back when Portman was 14, she was the face of Isaac Mizrahi, who would go on to cause a minor scandal at the Golden Globes two years ago, when he grabbed Johansson’s breasts. “Seriously, I would want to grab them. She’s got beautiful ones, but, Isaac, that was not so appropriate.”
And, of course, while Portman is famously Jewish, Johansson is a lesser-known Jew (because of her Scandinavian father, she’s called “the kosher Danish”). When Penelope Cruz and Salma Hayek made a movie together, all the headlines blared “the Hot Tamales”. What should the media label a film starring two Jewish girls? Portman doesn’t miss a beat.
“The Hot Knishes,” she says, referring to the Jewish delicacy. She says how good Johansson is, adding that in her own forthcoming film, My Blueberry Nights, Rachel Weisz “will knock your socks off”. But her favourite co-star of all time?
“Stephen Fry, when we made V for Vendetta. I wanted to spend all my time with him. He is awesome.” She thinks they gelled because they have anachronistic personalities. “I would much rather read a book or write a letter than watch television or send an e-mail. And I value good spelling. Spelling errors are a total pet peeve, which is embarrassing.”
Not that she is the paragon of refinement that her face would lead you to believe. “My Hallowe’en costume the last year of high school was a hooker,” she admits. An elegant, gamine hooker? “No,” she laughs, tea dripping onto her cashmere. “Just a hooker, with lots of bad make-up.”

Friday, February 22, 2008

El Factor H

Mis diez puntos sobre La traición de Rita Hayworth
1. El Factor Traición: identidad de Rita Hayworth relativa a los padres de Toto: ¿quién es Rita la traidora: representa Rita al padre o a la madre? ¿es posible establecer sólo al padre o sólo a la madre, respectivamente, como la persona que traiciona a Toto proyectada en la figura de Rita? ¿es posible separar o dividir a los padres de su doble relación con la traidora Rita? ¿traiciona sólo el padre, sólo la madre, o traicionan ambos padres?
2. ¿se identifica Toto con la madre (y por lo mismo copia de ella su elección femenina del objeto amado masculino: el padre, los hombres)?
3. Si Toto ama a su padre Berto como lo ama Mita; si Toto ama a su padre como Mita ama a su esposo, ¿puede Toto amar a otro varón u otra hembra sin traicionar a su madre o a su padre?
4. Es decir, si la imagen de Rita Hayworth en la conciencia de Toto erotiza su propio amor por uno o por ambos padres, por Berto y por Mita, ¿quiere decir esto que cuando Toto se enamore de otra persona que no sea su padre o su madre traicionará a su padre o a su madre?
5. ¿Quiere decir esto que el presunto amor homosexual hacia otro hombre por parte de Toto, cuando sea adulto, será una traición del amor filial y erótico suyo por su padre?
6. ¿Quiere decir, por otro lado, que el posible amor no homosexual de Toto por una mujer será una traición a su madre?
7. El factor H ¿No será que Héctor representa la alternativa sexual de Toto con su madre? Es decir: que Héctor, no siendo hijo verdadero de Mita, sino su sobrino, representa—como macho viril—la alternativa (simultáneamente incestuosa y no incestuosa) de Toto como amante de su propia madre. (NOTA: Aunque la frecuencia de matrimonios entre tíos y sobrinas es mucho mayor que entre tías y sobrinos, así todo, tal relación no es desconocida, aunque se le considere en la gran mayoría de los sistemas legales como incestuosa (cualitativamente más incestuosa que la del tío con la sobrina) Debemos recordar que el escritor peruano Mario Vargas Llosa estuvo casado por un tiempo con una de sus tías, lo cual hizo objeto de una novela: La tía Julia y el escribidor)
8. Además: Héctor podría representar (en su carácter de “hijo” de su tía) ese otro hijo que nunca existió que la madre de Toto habría tenido con otro hombre que no fuera el padre de Toto. Es decir, Héctor podría representar el hijo adúltero de la infidelidad de su madre con el hermano de su marido, con su cuñado (la fobia de Hamlet Jr. cuya madre traicionó a su padre, Hamlet Sr., con su hermano Claudio).
9. Tesis. El factor Héctor representa el prejuicio que consiste en relacionar el amor homosexual con el incesto. Considerar las relaciones homosexuales como patrón (Standard) de incesto. Por ejemplo, este recorte de prensa: “I think if you legalize [gay marriage], you’ve got to legalize some other things that are pretty unsavory. You can call me a radical, but how can you tell an aunt that she can’t marry her nephew if they are really in love and sharing the bills? How can you tell them they can’t get married, but something else that’s unnatural can happen?”
10. Héctor, como alter ego heterosexual de Toto, su primo y hermano adoptivo, representa el mayor grado erótico de la relación masculina con la madre como objeto deseado. Por un lado, el Toto homosexual se enamora de su madre queriendo ser ella misma y amar lo mismo que ella ama. Por otro lado, proyectado en Héctor, Toto representa el amor erótico de su madre por el hijo/sobrino viril. En cuyo caso, la señal de virilidad viene ligada con el fantasma de la mujer traidora que engaña a su esposo con otro hombre con el cual tiene un hijo que será falsamente atribuido al esposo engañado.

Wednesday, February 20, 2008

Rita y la fluidez

He aquí un pasaje de SEXUAL FLUIDITY:Understanding Women’s Love and Desire by LISA M. DIAMOND (Harvard University Press, 2008).

Consideren la siguiente pregunta sobre "la traición de Rita Hayworth" y la fantasía de “La Mujer Araña.” En ambos casos se trata de la conciencia o fantasía de un varón (de un hombre) sobre una mujer en particular y sobre la Mujer. En ambos casos la posición sexual y deseos de la mujer se afirman y se fijan en forma inversa a la fluidez. ¿No será que el varón u hombre (aunque sea desde la perspectiva “gay” de querer ser mujer) no es capaz de la “fluidez” sexual que la profesora Diamond postula en el caso de la sexualidad de las mujeres? Este tema será considerado en las próximas clases.


CHAPTER 1

Will the Real Lesbians
Please Stand Up?


In 1997, the actress Anne Heche began a widely publicized romantic
relationship with the openly lesbian comedian Ellen DeGeneres
after having had no prior same-sex attractions or relationships.
The relationship with DeGeneres ended after two years, and Heche
went on to marry a man. The actress Cynthia Nixon of the HBO
series Sex and the City developed a serious relationship with a
woman in 2004 after ending a fifteen-year relationship with a man.
Julie Cypher left a heterosexual marriage for the musician Melissa
Etheridge in 1988. After twelve years together, the pair separated
and Cypher—like Heche—has returned to heterosexual relationships.
In other cases, longtime lesbians have unexpectedly initiated
relationships with men, sometimes after decades of exclusively
same-sex ties (examples include the feminist folk singer Holly Near,
the activist and writer Jan Clausen, and Deborah Sundahl, a founding
editor of the lesbian magazine On Our Backs). What’s going
on? Are these women confused? Were they just going through a
phase before, or are they in one now?

Consider, too, the growing number of popular terms that have
been coined to describe women with changing patterns of same-
sex and other-sex behavior, such as “heteroflexibility,” “has-bian,”
and “LUG—lesbian until graduation.”1 This new lexicon has been
matched by increasing media depictions of women who pursue



2• SEXUAL FLUIDITY

sexual contact that runs counter to their avowed sexual orientation,
ranging from the much-ballyhooed kiss between Madonna
and Britney Spears at the MTV Video Music Awards to films such
as Kissing Jessica Stein and Chasing Amy, which depicts a lesbian
becoming involved with a man, contrary to the more widespread
depictions of heterosexual women becoming involved in same-sex
relationships.

The reason such cases are so perplexing is that they flatly contradict
prevailing assumptions about sexual orientation. These assumptions
hold that an individual’s sexual predisposition for the
same sex or the other sex is an early-developing and stable trait that
has a consistent effect on that person’s attractions, fantasies, and
romantic feelings over the lifespan. What few people realize, however,
is that these assumptions are based primarily on men’s experiences
because most research on sexual orientation has been
conducted on men.2 Although this model of sexual orientation describes
men fairly accurately, it does not always apply so well to
women.

Historically, women who deviated from this model by reporting
shifts in their sexuality over time—heterosexual women falling in
love with female friends, lesbian women periodically dating men—
were presumed few in number and exceptional in nature. In other
words, they were just inconvenient noise cluttering up the real data
on sexual orientation. Yet as research on female sexuality has increased
over the years, these “exceptional” cases now appear to be
more common than previously thought. In short, the current conventional
wisdom about the nature and development of sexual orientation
provides an incomplete picture of women’s experiences.
Researchers now openly acknowledge that despite significant advances
in the science of sexuality over the past twenty years, “female
sexual orientation is, for the time being, poorly understood.”3

This situation is now changing. As scientists have begun investigating
female and male sexual orientation as distinct phenomena



Will the Real Lesbians Please Stand Up? • 3

instead of two sides of the same coin, consensus is gradually building
on why women appear so different from men. Specifically, we
have found that one of the fundamental, defining features of female
sexual orientation is its fluidity. We are now on the brink of a revolutionary
new understanding of female sexuality that has profound
scientific and social implications.

A Brief History of Fluidity

Sexual fluidity, quite simply, means situation-dependent flexibility
in women’s sexual responsiveness. This flexibility makes it possible
for some women to experience desires for either men or women under
certain circumstances, regardless of their overall sexual orientation.
In other words, though women—like men—appear to be born
with distinct sexual orientations, these orientations do not provide
the last word on their sexual attractions and experiences. Instead,
women of all orientations may experience variation in their erotic
and affectional feelings as they encounter different situations, relationships,
and life stages. This is why a woman like Anne Heche can
suddenly find herself falling madly in love with Ellen DeGeneres after
an exclusively heterosexual past, and why a longtime lesbian
can experience her very first other-sex attractions in her late forties.

The notion of sexual fluidity is not a new one. Rather, evidence
for this phenomenon has circulated in the scientific literature for
decades, though it has tended to be “submerged in the data rather
than explicitly theorized.”4 Some of the earliest discussions of flexible,
changeable patterns of sexuality came from sex researchers
who kept finding perplexing cases of same-sex sexuality “in some
unexpected places and among some apparently heterosexual people.”
5 For example, in 1977 the psychologists Erich Goode and
Lynn Haber published a study analyzing “experimental” same-sex
behavior pursued by college women who identified themselves as
heterosexual.6 They concluded that though some of these women



4• SEXUAL FLUIDITY

appeared to be headed toward lesbianism, others simply seemed to
be adventurous and open-minded about their sexuality. Similarly,
in the late 1970s the sociologists Philip Blumstein and Pepper
Schwartz conducted a groundbreaking study of more than 150 men
and women with bisexual patterns of sexual behavior. They found
that though some of their respondents had experienced same-sex
desires for many years, others appeared to have undergone major
changes in their sexual attractions.7 They concluded that early
childhood influences on sexuality (whatever they may be) were not
immutable, and that most individuals were unaware of their own
capacity for change in sexuality over time.

In interviews with fourteen nonheterosexual women, the psychologist
Joan Sophie found that many of the women experienced
unexpected transitions in their self-identification and sexual expression
over time. Sophie concluded that conventional identity models,
with their emphasis on fixed selves, needed to be revised to account
for such changes.8 Fritz Klein, Barry Sepekoff, and Timothy Wolf
eventually took up the call and developed a new approach to measuring
sexual orientation (the Klein Sexual Orientation Grid, or
KSOG), which for the first time considered the element of time.9 Individuals
rated their current, past, and “ideal” patterns of attraction,
behavior, and identity, making explicit the existence of prior
and perhaps future change. However, this time-sensitive approach
did not take hold, and researchers generally continued assessing
only current attractions, identities, and behaviors.

Around the same time, other academic fields began giving greater
consideration to sexual fluidity. In 1984 the anthropologist Gilbert
Herdt published a now-famous account of ritualized homosexuality
among adolescent boys in Melanesia.10 What was notable about
this practice was its developmental specificity. Unmarried men pursued
only same-sex encounters during their adolescent years out of
a belief that this practice was necessary for them to reach full maturity
as men. Once they were adults, same-sex activity ceased (with a



Will the Real Lesbians Please Stand Up? • 5

few exceptions); they then married and pursued only other-sex activity.
Herdt’s account of such an abrupt developmental transition
from same-sex to other-sex sexuality showed that our Western notion
of fixed sexual “orientations” was culturally specific. We might
view homosexuality as an inborn predisposition, but other cultures
expected and even arranged for drastic changes in same-sex and
other-sex desires and practices over the life course.

The anthropologist Evelyn Blackwood made the same observation
in her extensive review of female same-sex sexuality across
non-Western cultures, underscoring the limitations of the Western
notion of fixed sexual orientations. These perspectives were consistent
with a broad class of social constructionist models of sexuality
(discussed in more detail in the next chapter), which posited
that sexual identities did not exist as fixed types but were created
and given meaning through social interactions and cultural ideologies.
11 Most of the scholars advocating this perspective were not
specifically interested in sexual fluidity, but they highlighted the evidence
for it in order to challenge conventional, biologically determinist
views of sexuality.

The poet Adrienne Rich was one of the first people to discuss
fluidity’s specific relevance to female sexuality, and she took one of
the broadest and most explicitly political perspectives on the issue.
12 Rich argued that women throughout history and across a variety
of different cultures had always managed to form intimate,
emotionally primary ties to other women, despite the persistent
efforts of male-dominated societies to rigidly channel them into
heterosexual reproduction. Rich argued that all intense bonds between
women, even if they were not explicitly sexual, occupied a
“lesbian continuum” that ranged from purely emotional relationships
to sexual liaisons. This model suggested that regardless of
whether a woman currently experienced clear-cut same-sex desires,
she maintained a capacity for diverse forms of same-sex intimacy
and eroticism.



6• SEXUAL FLUIDITY

In the 1980s, the empirical evidence for sexual fluidity and its
disproportionate prevalence in women increased. For example, in
their study of gay, lesbian, bisexual, and heterosexual people living
in San Francisco in the 1980s, Martin Weinberg, Colin Williams,
and Douglas Pryor found that many of their participants—but especially
the women—recalled experiencing both minor and major
changes over time in their sexual attractions. This finding led the researchers
to conclude that “sexual preference is not always a fixed
phenomenon.” Although gay, lesbian, and heterosexual people reported
smaller and less frequent changes than did bisexuals, Weinberg
and his colleagues attributed this difference to the anchoring
effects of claiming a gay, lesbian, or heterosexual identity, since
such identities have “definable boundaries that can restrict the ability
or desire to explore change.”13 They came to the conclusion that
some degree of fluidity was a general property of sexuality, a view
that already had a steady group of adherents at that time, and
which continues to be influential.14 Although Weinberg, Williams,
and Pryor observed more sizable and frequent changes among their
female respondents, they did not advance an explanation for this
difference, except to speculate that it might have to do with the
women’s involvement with lesbian and feminist groups, which often
encouraged women to question their sexual identities.

The psychologist Carla Golden provided some of the most compelling
discussions to date of diversity and variability in female sexuality
in her interview study of heterosexual, bisexual, and lesbian
women in their twenties, thirties, and forties.15 She specifically analyzed
the contexts that elicited sexual transitions, for example, political
organizations and women’s studies classes. Golden argued
against the notion that such experiences simply prompted women
to “discover” long-suppressed same-sex orientations. Rather, she
argued that in some cases, same-sex sexuality “may have started as
an idea but it did not remain purely in the cognitive realm.” In
other words, women were capable of real change occurring in real
time.16



Will the Real Lesbians Please Stand Up? • 7

As for the causes underlying such changes, the psychologists Celia
Kitzinger and Sue Wilkinson emphasized sociocultural influences
and opportunities. They interviewed women who undertook abrupt
transitions from heterosexuality to lesbianism in mid-to late adulthood,
and concluded that such women “are no more driven by biology
or subconscious urges than they are when, for instance, they
change jobs; such choices could be viewed as influenced by a mixture
of personal reevaluation, practical necessity, political values,
chance, and opportunity.”17 The sociologist Paula Rust also emphasized
complex interactions between personal and cultural factors
that led some women to adopt different sexual identities and different
practices at different times of life, depending on their circumstances.
18

The role of intimate emotional relationships as a catalyst for
change in women’s sexuality was also gaining attention. The psychologist
Rebecca Shuster, for example, noted that “often women
fall in love with someone of an unexpected gender, and the power
of that relationship pulls them to re-evaluate their identity.” She
argued that such experiences “uncover a range of sexual and emotional
attraction and closeness of infinite variety” and pose an inevitable
challenge to the notion of fixed sexual identities.19 The
psychologist Vivian Cass made similar observations, noting that
same-sex emotional ties were particularly influential for women: “It
is not uncommon to see a woman who in mid-life ‘falls in love’ with
another woman for the first time in her life. This experience may
not necessarily include sexual responses, although the quality of the
emotional experience is similar to other love relationships she may
have had with men. Where a sexual component does become present,
this may occur after a period of time or after the emotional responses
have been reciprocated.”20 Other researchers had begun to
wrestle with these apparent gender differences. The sociologist Vera
Whisman conducted a comparison of lesbians’ and gay men’s personal
understandings of the causes of their same-sex sexuality. She
found that men were significantly more likely to view their sexual




8• SEXUAL FLUIDITY

ity as fixed and innate, whereas women more often acknowledged a
role for specific relationships, choice, change, and circumstance.21

Current Perspectives

The psychologist Roy Baumeister was the first researcher to synthesize
these accumulating strands of evidence into a comprehensive
argument for female sexual variability.22 Several years ago he
published a review of the extensive psychological, historical, and
sociological evidence suggesting that women’s sexuality is more
“plastic” than men’s. His notion of “plasticity” includes not just
same-sex and other-sex sexuality but also overall sex drive, desired
partner characteristics, preferred sexual practices, and consistency
between attitudes and behaviors. His work provides critical support
for the notion of a robust gender difference in women’s capacity
for sexual variability. Note that I use the term “sexual fluidity”
to distinguish flexibility in same-sex and other-sex sexuality, which
is the topic of this book, from the broader forms of variability in
sexual attitudes and practices discussed by Baumeister.

New research has provided even more support for the notion of
gender differences. One study (described in detail in Chapter 4)
found that both lesbian and heterosexual women became physically
aroused by visual images of both men and women. In contrast,
men’s responses fell in line with their self-described sexual orientations.
23 That said, genital responses should not be considered more
accurate measures of desire than individuals’ own subjective experiences
(in fact, interpretation of genital arousal in such studies has
long been controversial). But such findings certainly dovetail with
the extensive evidence suggesting a pervasive gender difference in
erotic variability and flexibility.

Not all sex researchers agree with this view. Some have argued
strongly against the notion of a gender difference in fluidity, maintaining
that women’s apparently greater sexual variability might be
due to social and cultural factors.24 Blumstein and Schwartz, for ex

Boquitas pintadas de rojo carmesí

This is from Lucille Kerr’s chapter on Boquitas pintadas in her excellent book, Suspended Fictions: Reading Novels By Manuel Puig
Boquitas pintadas, Puig’s second novel, opens with a display of death—an obituary notice that announces the demise of Juan Carlos Etchepare, the small-time, small-town Don Juan who functions as both a seductive model and a model of seduction in this text.’ This written verification of closure on the life of the novel’s protagonist seems to offer us a sign of the finite nature of a text which might otherwise appear ready and able to go on forever. Along with the proliferation of distinct narrative and discursive forms within its pages, the generic model that the formal design of Boquitas pintadas is supposed to replicate—the serial(ized) novel (i.e., folletín) named in its subtitle—suggests a text potentially out of control, a text that might threaten to regenerate itself without end. Yet Boquitas pintadas is in many ways a controlled text, one whose constituent parts seem to have been organized and articulated by an authorial figure whose own ludic performance and position are also brought to light by it. Within this meticulously ordered network we come to see a kind of “perfect match” between thematic material and structural machinery; it works to keep things open by turning them around. Moreover, this match discloses the image of an authority who, not unlike the novel’s protagonist, seems to become caught in the act of plotting maneuvers that in the end may signal his own undoing.
Boquitas pintadas can be read as a play among discursive, thematic, and structural contracts that implicate not only the authority behind but also the literary and cultural traditions that surround the text. In this second novel the articulation of thematic and textual elements derived from diverse literary, subliterary, and nonliterary models makes the novel into a meeting-ground for discourses of both “high” and “low” origin. Like Puig’s other novels, this one seems to present both parodic and stylized treatments of the generic, thematic, and linguistic paradigms to which it refers. Here Puig appears to identify with and to take seriously, but also to take a distance from and to scrutinize, the many texts and traditions that are brought together in the novel. This sentimental, even tragic, view of a world whose codes are both valorized and criticized is developed by a textual authority whose efforts to demystify parts of that reality are, we could argue, also betrayed by the seductive powers of those same objects of scrutiny. Not unlike La traición de Rita Hayworth, Boquitas pintadas constructs a network of dialogues from whose ground both authorial and readerly images, as well as the fictional characters around whom they revolve, emerge as problematical, mobile fictions.
Submit to me as before ten bullet point comments on Boquitas pintadas or Heartbreak Tango.

Friday, February 15, 2008

Gilda con Rita

Traidor, traidora, traidores: entregar, entregarse

«Todos los hombres que conozco se acuestan con Gilda, pero se levantan conmigo». R.H.

“traduttore, tradittore” (traductor, traidor: traduttora, tradittora)

UNA manera de traducir (y traicionar) la frase de Rita Hayworth sobre el deseo de los hombres por ella es: “Todos los machos que conozco se acuestan entregándose a Gilda y se levantan entregados a mí.” Lo cual implica que el hombre o el macho se ha traicionado a sí mismo al entregarse a una mujer creyendo entregarse a otra: Gilda y Rita no son la misma cosa. Valga la palabra “cosa”: en lugar o como traducción de la hembra transformada en la imaginación del varón en objeto o cosa de fantasía. En su origen etimológico la palabra “traición” viene del latín traditio y tradere – que quieren decir “entregar” (to hand-over – to give forth). En este sentido, traicionar quiere decir entregarse a otra persona o causa que no sea la debida, la persona o causa a la cual uno o una corresponde o pertenece.
En la clase de ayer vimos escenas cinematográficas en las cuales se muestra cómicamente la fantasía viril de la mujer como maquina, como artefacto letal, bomba, explosivo. También (en la escena en la cabina del bombardero) vimos cómo la mujer pierde la cabeza cuando se sienta al timón del aeroplano controlada por la simulación del hombre que quiere aprovecharse de ella para “cogérsela” (Argentina). La mujer en esta escena es traicionada (es entregada al hombre) por su propia imaginación controlada por algo externo a su voluntad: auto-traición: traidora y traductora de sí misma. También se puede decir que el hombre que la manipula la entrega a esa otra cosa o persona en ella que no es ella, que la traduce y traiciona en algo que ella no controla. Estando falsamente al control del aeroplano, ella se descontrola en favor del hombre.
Pero hay otra forma de traición, entrega y descontrol. El mismo hombre que se aprovecha de la mujer y sus fantasías con volar un avión de guerra es el hombre que considera a la mujer como su traidora virtual en todo momento. Para él, la mujer es capaz en todo momento de traicionar al hombre, a cualquier hombre (esta mujer traidora: ¿será Gilda?). ¿Al acostarse con Gilda, se acuesta el hombre con una traidora? ¿Quién es la verdadera traidora, Gilda, la mujer con la cual uno se acuesta, o Rita, la mujer con la cual uno se levanta? La fantasía llamada Gilda controla o sustituye a la persona real llamada Rita. ¿Es Gilda quien traiciona a Rita o se trata de Rita que traiciona a Gilda?
Por último, la fantasía del hombre por y con Gilda representa su propia traición masculina a Rita. El hombre que se acuesta con Gilda traiciona a Rita traicionándose a sí mismo. El hombre se entrega (se traiciona) a sí mismo entregándose a Gilda y traicionando a Rita. En esta fantasía con el sexo opuesto, el sexo del hombre representa al sexo de la mujer como la traición o entrega de su propio sexo. Según esta fantasía sexual y sexista, el sexo del hombre se ve traicionado en y por el sexo de la mujer.
Escriban el comentario requerido según lo explicado en clase. Tienen que contribuir diez (10) cuestiones básicas (bullet points) sobre la trama de La traición de Rita Hayworth.

Thursday, February 14, 2008

Toto vs. Héctor: pulsiones orales

Querida Mónica,
Como hacía unos diez años que no releía La traición de Rita Hayworth, estoy un poco en alta mar, redescubriéndola. Volviendo al tema de Toto y Teté y mi referencia a la tanatonomía de la niña, el imaginario de la chica entrando en la pubertad está lleno de imágenes de muerte: empleo este término sólo para subrayar el trabajo de la muerte (tanatos) en la economía: manejo o leyes (nomos) del hogar (oikos). Es un caso de labor de luto (work of mourning). Esa tanatografía o tanatopraxie (Derrida: Glas. 99b), el trabajo de pompa fúnebre, de amortajamiento, verbal en este caso, hacen de la niña Teté algo más que un mero ejemplo deplorable de obsesión religiosa por lavado de cerebro. Representa ella, me parece, el rostro adverso del imaginario fílmico/Hollywood de Toto. De hecho, el imaginario fílmico ya de por sí representa algo parecido al trabajo gráfico de la muerte en la imaginación. Pues las películas que comparten Mita y Toto constituyen una especie de museograma, un CD ROM o DVD Special Features en que quedan grabadas las imágenes eternas de personajes y estrellas desaparecidos (palabra que empleo con timbre o dejo argentino). Las personas fílmicas representarían el culto a los ancestros vivos o revividos cada vez que se contempla la cinta.
Bueno, pasando a Héctor, que era el personaje que más (o mejor) se me había olvidado. Más allá de la autopsia parlante del machismo argentino que se escenifica en su persona, me interesa poner en juego lo siguiente. Me concentro en dos grupos de frases.
En el primero (según la voz de “Delia, verano 1943” Capítulo VII) se trata del contagio verbal de Héctor hacia Mita: “una lengua de carrero tiene el Héctor, y Mita se ha subido al carro con él.” (i.e. Héctor le dice a Mita: “planchame bien los talompas de la pilcha , no me las hagas ir de gilastro”) De momento, la lengua o jerga compartida no es abiertamente obscena. Pero yo creo que se trata de un regreso a la lengua primordial (a lo primordial de la lengua) a la ambivalencia de las palabras más viejas, que según Freud creaban una cámara de ecos siempre con lo sucio (en un principio no había voz que no fuera en sus reverberaciones cochina). El contagio oral entre Héctor y Mita tiene pues de incesto: en el sentido cabal de no casto, de sucio.
En el segundo ya se cae de lleno en el registro sexual, en la frase de Toto a Mita, sobre Héctor: “y sabés mamá, ayer le vi todo el pito cortado de tener malas costumbres, la sirvienta de enfrente la habrá hecho algo con la cuchilla.” Aunque no se trata de circuncisión sino de lastimaduras, (en las cuales el doctor Freud habría notado un referente al sexo angosto/anal) Toto, en su ignorancia, sí pone en juego el fantasma de la circuncisión practicada por la hembra. Es decir, como en el caso primitivo (Éxodo 4.24-26), en el cual Séphora es la que corta el prepucio de su hijo con Moisés y le dice: “a la verdad tú me eres un esposo de sangre”). Sin embargo, la madre Mita no capta bien el asunto de la herida del sobrino/hijo Héctor al contárselo a Berto, quien “por poco se mea de la risa” oyéndolo. Yo creo que la ciega inocencia de Mita, la madre/tía (en este caso, doble madre, que actúa en nombre suyo propio y en el de la madre muerta de Héctor) se podría estudiar según el texto de Derrida en Circonfession 43-44 (en Jacques Derrida, G. Bennington con J. Derrida). En dicho texto se celebra luctuosamente y con júbilo la muerte de la madre de Derrida, Mónica, y se relata el sueño adulto del hijo con la escena de amor incestuoso e inocente en la cual la madre corta (con la boca y se traga) el prepucio del hijo en una especie de festejo erótico.
En el tercero se remata el nexo oral entre Mita y Héctor. Me parece que juegan al truco (te pido que corrobores o corrigas esto): “[habla Héctor] se puso de pierna al truco con García y me lo pelamos a Berto, ‘quiero flor’ le digo a Mita y ella ‘flor de ojete tenés hermano, que no se dice ojete, se dice ano’ y García se puso colorado y Mita ‘a ojete colorado flor de patadas la han dado’” y Berto se mataba de la risa y el Toto con bronca.” No sé si me equivoco con lo del juego del truco, pero la obscenidad en labios de la madre/tía (o doble madre) es espectacular en su desvergüenza cómplice con Héctor.
Se podría resumir lo siguiente. Así como en el caso de Toto el nexo con la madre es de carácter escopofílico (Laura Mulvey's "Visual Pleasure")—por fijación ocular en la pantalla fílmica compartida con ella y recaptada en sucesivas narraciones—,en el caso de Héctor el nexo sería oral/anal en el dominio de lo oblativo, del don o regalo. Creo que Héctor le devuelve el goce cochino del oblativo parlante a su madre adoptiva en una especie de culto oral al deseo carnal.
Salud,

EG

flecha quiere decir veneno

El adictivo cóctel cerebral del amor
El enamoramiento hace al cerebro segregar sustancias con efectos similares a las drogas


ROSA M. TRISTÁN
MADRID.- La química del amor está en marcha: abrazos, caricias, miradas cómplices que no se ocultan al mundo. El enamoramiento entre el presidente francés Nicolas Sarkozy y la cantante Carla Bruni está en su fase álgida y sus cerebros, según las últimas investigaciones, están en ebullición eléctrica (por las descargas neuronales) y química (por las hormonas y sustancias que participan). Toda una droga.
Empezando por la infancia, algunas investigaciones apuntan que entre los cinco y los ocho años ya se desarrollan los moldes cerebrales que determinan de quién nos enamoramos. Por ello, a menudo el flechazo surge con personas parecidas a lo largo de toda la vida. "Para que se produzca, debe haber concordancia de interés entre las dos personas y que surjan recuerdos de otros momentos de atracción", explica José Luis González de Rivera, jefe de Psiquiatría en la Fundación Jiménez Díaz de Madrid.
A veces, añade este experto, es un amor de rebote, para acabar con el sufrimiento que produce una ruptura, el famoso "un clavo saca otro clavo", que es lo que podría haberle sucedido a Sarkozy tras ser abandonado por su mujer Cecilia. "Pero son enamoramientos a menudo decepcionantes, porque no se basan en la atracción por la otra persona. Es mejor esperar a deshabituarse del anterior", asegura este psiquiatra.
Y es que al enamorarse se provocan reacciones químicas adictivas, como con las drogas, y el desamor produce síndrome de abstinencia.
Para empezar, en contra de lo que se pensaba, las mujeres emiten feromonas al ovular, como otras hembras de animales. Son hormonas inodoras pero que perciben los hombres.
Un estudio publicado en la revista 'Evolución and Human Behavior' detectó que las 'strippers' ganan el doble cuando están ovulando que cuando tienen la menstruación, lo que sugiere que los hombres responden a esos estímulos olfativos. También se comprobó que los maridos son más celosos y más atentos sexualmente con sus esposas durante el periodo de ovulación.
Otros investigadores han demostrado que, por su parte, las mujeres detectan el complejo de histocompatibiblidad mayor (CHM) del sistema inmune, unos genes que producen olores diferentes, y sienten mayor atracción por los varones con un CHM diferente al propio.
Descarga química
Una vez encontrada la persona más atractiva, el sistema nervioso se pone en marcha y se produce una descarga de feniletilamina, un compuesto de la familia de las anfetaminas que desata la pasión. «Ella es la responsable de producir la excitación, la que hace que se produzca la dopamina, que es el neurotransmisor relacionado con el placer y la recompensa», comenta David Huertas, psiquiatra e investigador del Hospital de Guadalajara.
Huertas no duda de que en el futuro se fabricarán sustancias que favorezcan los enamoramientos con unas gotas de oxitocina (la hormona de la confianza y el apego), serotonina (que genera bienestar), dopamina y noradrenalina (que dilata las pupilas y acelera la tensión).
De ese cóctel explosivo es del que surge, según los últimos estudios, el enamoramiento y la adicción a esos arrebatos de los que no se libra ni Sarkozy, aunque su popularidad caiga en picado.
Otra hormona que está en activo es la testosterona. Se ha descubierto que la testosterona genera deseo sexual en las mujeres, en las que actúa como un afrodisíaco que se podría recibir de los besos de la pareja masculina.
Las resonancias magnéticas funcionales y la tomografías de positrones han ayudado mucho a conocer qué zonas del cerebro se encienden por amor. Según el equipo de Helen Fisher, son las áreas afectadas por la dopamina (que se produce en la zona tegmental ventral y se libera en el núcleo accumbens y la corteza frontal) las que se ponen al rojo vivo, así como el septum de las mujeres, una zona donde se sitúan las emociones, y la corteza visual en los hombres, donde se aprecia la belleza.
Los investigadores Samir Zeki y Andreas Bartels comprobaron que, además, se inhibe el córtex frontal, donde reside la racionalidad y el sentido crítico respecto a la pareja. Son las locuras del amor.
Una vez pasada la pasión, que dura meses, otras áreas comienzan a funcionar, las vitales en las relaciones duraderas. Por ello, una relación estable puede verse sorprendida por una aventura imprevista. En otros casos no se llega a la segunda fase, y con la pasión desaparece toda la atracción.

Wednesday, February 13, 2008

Wiki Rita

Rita Hayworth
Margarita Carmen Cansino, mejor conocida como Rita Hayworth, (Nueva York, 17 de octubre de 1918 — id., 14 de mayo de 1987) fue una famosa actriz de cine clásico estadounidense.
Biografía
Hija del bailarín Eduardo Cansino, natural de Castilleja de la Cuesta (Sevilla, España), y de Volga Haworth, de origen irlandés. Rita empezó su carrera como bailarina junto a su padre, Eduardo, y con su nombre real, a la temprana edad de 13 años.
Llegó a Hollywood en 1933, y, desde 1935, comenzó a actuar como actriz en papeles secundarios, realizando muchas películas de serie B en las que sobre todo destacó por sus dotes para la danza, o por su elegante aspecto. De esta etapa destaca la película Charlie Chan en Egipto (1937, de Louis King), película perteneciente a la saga dedicada al célebre detective oriental, en la que trabajó junto a Warner Oland, que encarnaba a Chan.
Fue su marido por aquel entonces, Edward Judson, quien la lanzó al estrellato convirtiéndola en su mejor inversión personal. Judson le consiguió un contrato con Columbia Pictures, productora que necesitaba de estrellas importantes y a quien la actriz acabaría colocando entre las primeras compañías cinematográficas ("Rita Hayworth es la Columbia", dijo Frank Sinatra), reportándole millonarios ingresos sólo con su presencia. En dicha tesitura, Harry Cohn, magnate de la productora, se enamoró de ella. La presión y las disputas por este motivo entre la actriz y el productor, darían mucho que hablar entre los profesionales de la industria, y él estuvo toda la vida obsesionado con ella, que no respondió a sus deseos.
Su primer papel importante fue como secundaria en una inolvidable película: Sólo los ángeles tienen alas (1939), de Howard Hawks, lo que hizo que la crítica también se empezara a fijar en ella. Rita Hayworth poseía una personalidad tímida y bondadosa, que contrastaba con su fuerza y enorme impacto en la pantalla. En este film, compartía cartel con Cary Grant, Jean Arthur y Thomas Mitchell, y entre tanto talento, supo destacar. Luego rodó una deliciosa comedia junto a Brian Aherne: Una dama en cuestión (1940, Charles Vidor).
Rita ingresó triunfante en la Twenty Century Fox (compañía que años atrás la rechazara) reclamada por Rouben Mamoulian para interpretar a Doña Sol en la superproducción basada en la novela de Vicente Blasco Ibáñez Sangre y arena (1941, Rouben Mamoulian), junto a Tyrone Power y Linda Darnell. Esta película significó su lanzamiento como sex symbol indiscutible durante toda una década. Su carrera ya era imparable y se convirtió en una de las más grandes estrellas de su época y en la actriz mejor pagada del cine.
Luego intervino en dos comedias musicales de amplio eco popular, junto a Fred Astaire (quién la consideró su mejor pareja de baile), y a quién empequeñeció en la pantalla: Desde aquel beso (1941), de Sidney Lamfield, y Bailando nace el amor (1942), de William A. Seiter. Estos éxitos y sus dotes para el género, la llevaron a protagonizar un musical ya clásico: Las modelos (1944, Charles Vidor), junto al mítico Gene Kelly y Phil Silvers, film innovador en su día por trasladar los números de baile de salón a ambientaciones callejeras. En esa época rodó, con James Cagney y Olivia de Havilland, un melodrama de primer orden (Pelirroja) dirigido por Raoul Walsh; una cinta biográfica junto a Victor Mature y Carole Landis titulada Mi chica favorita (1942, Irving Cummings), y un musical que fluctúa entre la comedia y el drama de tono menor, pero bastante satisfactorio: Esta noche y todas las noches (1945, Victor Saville), junto a Lee Bowman y Janet Blair.
Gilda
No obstante, su fama como mito erótico se consolidó con Gilda (1946), de Charles Vidor, una de las grandes películas del cine negro, en la que tan sólo con un brevísimo pero sugerente strip-tease y la recepción de una bofetada consiguió récords de taquilla en todo el mundo. Dicha bofetada se convertiría en la más famosa de la historia del cine; fue propinada por su pareja en el film, Glenn Ford, en respuesta a la que Hayworth le había propinado momentos antes.
La película fue un escándalo, y en países como España fue considerada como "Gravemente peligrosa" por la Iglesia Católica, debido a su strip-tease insinuante, en la famosa escena donde se quita un guante. Esta película la hizo inmensamente famosa, hasta el punto de que se colocó su imagen en la bomba atómica de pruebas arrojada por Estados Unidos sobre las Islas Bikini. Dado el carácter pacifista de la actriz, este hecho la indignó profundamente. También ocasionó una histérica expedición a los Andes para enterrar una copia de la película, para que se conservase en caso de un desastre nuclear.
Este momento de fama internacional también coincide con una de sus crisis en lo personal: su matrimonio con Ali Khan empieza a hacer aguas, y declara a la prensa (frase que se haría célebre): «Todos los hombres que conozco se acuestan con Gilda, pero se levantan conmigo».
La suerte profesional parece ir en racha, y en 1948 rueda junto a su nuevo marido, el director Orson Welles, un film en su día maldito pero de enorme trascendencia: La dama de Shangai.
La película no tuvo mucho éxito comercial, porque Welles le cortó el pelo, la tiñó de rubio platino, le dio un papel de arpía y la mató al final de la película, cosa que no gustó mucho a su público. Sin embargo forma parte de la mitología del cine por su narrativa, estilística y ritmo, y Rita Hayworth declaró años después que «sabía que estabamos haciendo un clásico mientras la rodábamos».
Gilda, el papel más importante de su carrera, fue también el que marcó el inicio de su declive como estrella de Hollywood, ya que nunca consiguió el mismo éxito como sex symbol en ninguna de sus películas posteriores. Sin embargo, fue y es la película que ha convertido a la actriz en inolvidable: "Nunca hubo una mujer como Gilda", se dijo.
Otros títulos destacados de su filmografía son Los amores de Carmen (1948) y La dama de trinidad (1952), que no lograron reeditar el éxito de Gilda, pese a repetir pareja protagonista (para el escritor y cinéfilo Terenci Moix, Rita fue la mejor 'Carmen' del cine); Salomé (1953), de William Dieterle, recreando la historia bíblica, junto a Stewart Granger y Charles Laughton; La bella del Pacífico (1953), de Curtis Bernhardt, reversionando un clásico de William Somerset Maugham ya adaptado para el cine con mejor fortuna en los años 20; Pal Joey (1957, George Sidney), junto a Frank Sinatra y Kim Novak, su último musical, rotundo triunfo de la actriz en su madurez física e interpretativa, rodando un número que ha pasado a la historia del género; Fuego escondido (1957, Robert Parrish), junto a Robert Mitchum y Jack Lemmon; y Mesas separadas (1958), junto a Burt Lancaster, Deborah Kerr, Wendy Hiller y David Niven.
Durante los años 60 y principios de los 70 trabajó en producciones modestas, de serie B y en algunas coproduciones europeas de aventuras o westerns mostrando su declive físico e intelectual (la enfermedad le impedía memorizar bien los guiones). De esta última etapa destacan tres títulos: Último chantaje (1962) junto a Rex Harrison, El aventurero (1967, Terence Young), junto a Anthony Quinn, y La ira de Dios (1972, Ralph Nelson), que fue su última interpretación en la gran pantalla.
Se llegó a casar 5 veces: las dos ya mencionadas, con Edward Judson y Orson Welles, pero también se casó con el príncipe Ali Khan, con el que tuvo una hija, la princesa Yasmina Khan; con el actor Dick Haymes, y con el director de cine James Hill (Nacida libre).
Rita fue víctima de la enfermedad de Alzheimer en una época en que este mal no estaba diagnosticado. Como muchas personas que la padecen, se dio a la bebida ante la desesperación y el desconcierto que le provocaban los síntomas. Murió en el año 1987, a los 68 años, víctima de dicha enfermedad, que padecía desde los años 60, pero que no le fue diagnosticada hasta 1980.
Rita Hayworth es considerada uno de los mitos indiscutibles del cine, una mujer de increíble belleza e instinto para la interpretación, con una personalidad y una profundidad que trascendió su trabajo en el cine y que, como afirmó el director George Cukor, consiguió que sus fans se interesasen por la persona más que por sus personajes.

Sunday, February 10, 2008

Correo con Suzanne Jill Levine: Toto at birth

--On Saturday, February 09, 2008 6:22 AM -0500 EDUARDO GONZALEZ
eduardo.gonzalez@jhu.edu> wrote:

Dear Spider Woman, in class the question has risen early: was Toto born
gay? What is the thrust of a book like BRH with respect to the genetics
vs. nurture -- or nature vs. environment -- polemics concerning male
homosexuality?

eg

dear Spider Man in John Waters territory: If you read the first chapter or
two of the bio--you definitely get the feeling his gayness started very
young, produced by the combo of his mother's needs and his father's
limitations. but oh dear, this sounds like dollar book Freud? As Madeleine
Kahn sang in Young Frankenstein,
"oh sweet mystery of life!"

xx :) sjl

La Traición de Rita Hayworth, Capítulo VI: la Teté

Correo con Mónica Zapata

Mónica Le 9 févr. 08 à 17:22, EDUARDO GONZALEZ a écrit :

Querida Mónica, debí acusarte recibo más pronto de la llegada de los artículos. Los leeremos en unos días. Estamos por La traición. Hacía tiempo, unos quince años, que no la releía. Tengo unas acotaciones y preguntas que compartir.
El capítulo VI (“Teté, invierno 1942”). Me parece suscita un contrapunteo entre Teté y Toto (a partir inclusive de las sílabas nominales). Por un lado las películas del niño y por otro las visiones de ella, de carácter religioso y fóbico (dos imaginarios homólogos por alteridad). Además, la relación con cada padre: con Berto, el sentimiento de abandono y traición que siente el niño porque su padre no comparte con él el mundo de las películas; y, de parte de la niña, el padre que la compara con el sol, para compensar su aparente desvalidez. Percibo un aspecto tanatonómico en los lamentos de la niña, en su obsesión con la muerte: no sólo con las enfermedades sino, en la escena en que espía por la cerradura el baño de Toto con Mita, y su desaparición en la bañadera, y luego el color blanco, mortal, con que sale Toto del baño con la madre. Al final del capítulo, la frase de la niña a su padre, “pero yo sé que las vas a apagar, [las luces]” resulta curiosa porque “pagar” y “apagar” son homólogas en su raíz: “apaciguar” y también lo que en inglés se llama atonement o expiar. En la frase anterior se confunden a nivel fónico “las vas a apagar” con “las vas a pagar” – si se asume con rigor el tema principal sobre la traición (con el tema implícito o concomitante de tener que expiar) no deja de llamar la atención que la niña se obsesione de manera paralela con las obsesiones propias de Toto con su padre, pero de modo explícito y respecto a un padre que precisamente no sería merecedor de esa demanda suya, de la niña: la demanda de que apague, pague, expíe. Me recuerda lo de Freud sobre el masoquismo en el caso concreto de “le pegan a un niño” – quiero decir que en el caso de la niña la obsesión existe respecto a algo inmotivado, que se registra a un nivel profundamente inconsciente. El padre tiene que “pagar” por algo que su conducta no ocasiona e inclusive desvirtúa: el buen padre queda bajo reproche y demanda por insuficiencia. Es decir, Teté trata a su buen padre como Toto debe tratar al suyo, quien sí se merece el reproche por no corresponder a sus deseos filiales de una manera adecuada. Sería en la voz de la futura mujer y quizás madre, Teté, que lo inmotivado, el saldo de insatisfacción radical de la fémina hacia el varón, se registra. Por fémina me refiero a la posición “femenina” en Freud y el complejo del masoquismo (para ambos sexos) inherente en dicha posición…
Pronto te voy a mandar un par impresiones cautelares sobre Hector. Pero entretanto, te pregunto si las “negras” sirvientes del capítulo VII son afro-argentinas.

Un abrazo,

EG

Querido Eduardo:

Me alegro de que hayan llegado ya los textos, los mandé lo antes posible para que tuvieran tiempo de leerlo, pero el snail-mail francés funciona muy bien!

Acabo de releer los dos capítulos de La Traición que mencionas:

VI, Teté: ¡que espanto es esa nena! Sí, me parece también que el capítulo y los nombres Teté/Toto están en contrapunto. Pero las visiones de Toto son más "festivas", o eufóricas (como las de Puig?) mientra que las de Teté son decididamente apocalípticas. También veo un contrapunto en los colores: blanco/ azul - naranja.
Me llama la atención el sentimiento de culpa de Teté cuando ella no hace nada malo, y la "no culpa" de Toto, que en realidad hace todo lo que los padres no quisieran que haga.
El padre castigador es Berto, por cierto, y no el de Teté. Pero hay un machismo terrible en los dos padres y en la educación de la niña que desde ya teme todo cuanto venga de los varones.
No había notado la homología de los significantes: "pagar" "apagar": me parece que sí, Teté tiene que expiar algo que no se ha producido (la muerte de la madre). Sí, me parece que el tema está en relación con los de "Traición/ decepción" (de los que habla, por ejemplo René Campos, en La textura cinemática …, p. 113) y que hay un masoquismo en la niña que no veo en Toto, que es un pequeño perverso, pero según otra modalidad, más creativa. Le voy a pasar tus comentarios a un amigo que ha hecho su tesis sobre Puig y ha analizado mucho los significantes desde una perspectiva lacaniana: Gérald Larrieu.

En cuanto a las "negras", del capítulo VII: en sentido estricto, no hay negras en la Argentina, al menos no de origen africano. Pero la clase burguesa o pequeño burguesa ha llamado siempre "negro/negra" a la clase popular (cf. los "cabecitas negras" de Perón) de origen a menudo amerindio (de pelo negro y tez más bien oscura). Tampoco el "turco" Yamil es de origen turco sino, probablemente, siriolibanés como parte de la población del Noroeste argentino (provincia de Santiago del Estero sobre todo).

Espero con ansias las notas sobre Héctor!

Un gran abrazo


Mónica

Thursday, February 7, 2008

Toto, his mother, the movies, and hormones

you can go to wikipedia under oxytocin

Actions
Oxytocin has peripheral (hormonal) actions, and also has actions in the brain. The actions of oxytocin are mediated by specific, high affinity oxytocin receptors. The oxytocin receptor is a G-protein-coupled receptor which requires Mg2+ and cholesterol. It belongs to the rhodopsin-type (class I) group of G-protein-coupled receptors.


[edit] Peripheral (hormonal) actions
The peripheral actions of oxytocin mainly reflect secretion from the pituitary gland. (See oxytocin receptor for more detail on its action.)

Letdown reflex – in lactating (breastfeeding) mothers, oxytocin acts at the mammary glands, causing milk to be 'let down' into a collecting chamber, from where it can be extracted by sucking at the nipple. Sucking by the infant at the nipple is relayed by spinal nerves to the hypothalamus. The stimulation causes neurons that make oxytocin to fire action potentials in intermittent bursts; these bursts result in the secretion of pulses of oxytocin from the neurosecretory nerve terminals of the pituitary gland.
Uterine contraction – important for cervical dilation before birth and causes contractions during the second and third stages of labor. Oxytocin release during breastfeeding causes mild but often painful uterine contractions during the first few weeks of lactation. This also serves to assist the uterus in clotting the placental attachment point postpartum. However, in knockout mice lacking the oxytocin receptor, reproductive behavior and parturition is normal.[3]
The relationship between oxytocin and human sexual response is unclear. At least two non-controlled studies have found increases in plasma oxytocin at orgasm – in both men and women.[4][5] The authors of one of these studies speculated that oxytocin's effects on muscle contractibility may facilitate sperm and egg transport.[4] Murphy et al. (1987), studying men, found that oxytocin levels were raised throughout sexual arousal and there was no acute increase at orgasm. [6] A more recent study of men found an increase in plasma oxytocin immediantly after orgasm, but only in a portion of their sample that did not reach statistical significance. The authors noted that these changes "may simply reflect contractile properties on reproductive tissue."[7]
Due to its similarity to vasopressin, it can reduce the excretion of urine slightly. More important, in several species, oxytocin can stimulate sodium excretion from the kidneys (natriuresis), and in humans, high doses of oxytocin can result in hyponatremia.
Oxytocin and oxytocin receptors are also found in the heart in some rodents, and the hormone may play a role in the embryonal development of the heart by promoting cardiomyocyte differentiation. [8][9] However, the absence of either oxytocin or its receptor in knockout mice has not been reported to produce cardiac insufficiencies.[3]

[edit] Actions of oxytocin within the brain
Oxytocin secreted from the pituitary gland cannot re-enter the brain because of the blood-brain barrier. Instead, the behavioral effects of oxytocin are thought to reflect release from centrally projecting oxytocin neurons, different from those that project to the pituitary gland. Oxytocin receptors are expressed by neurons in many parts of the brain and spinal cord, including the amygdala, ventromedial hypothalamus, septum and brainstem.

Sexual arousal. Oxytocin injected into the cerebrospinal fluid causes spontaneous erections in rats,[10] reflecting actions in the hypothalamus and spinal cord.
Bonding. In the Prairie Vole, oxytocin released into the brain of the female during sexual activity is important for forming a monogamous pair bond with her sexual partner. Vasopressin appears to have a similar effect in males.[11] In people, plasma concentrations of oxytocin have been reported to be higher amongst people who claim to be falling in love. Oxytocin has a role in social behaviors in many species, and so it seems likely that it has similar roles in humans.
Autism. A 1998 study found significantly lower levels of oxytocin in blood plasma of autistic children.[12] A 2003 study found a decrease in autism spectrum repetitive behaviors when oxytocin was administered intravenously.[13] A 2007 study reported that oxytocin helped autistic adults retain the ability to evaluate the emotional significance of speech intonation.[14]
Maternal behavior. Sheep and rat females given oxytocin antagonists after giving birth do not exhibit typical maternal behavior. By contrast, virgin female sheep show maternal behavior towards foreign lambs upon cerebrospinal fluid infusion of oxytocin, which they would not do otherwise. [15]
Increasing trust and reducing fear. In a risky investment game, experimental subjects given nasally administered oxytocin displayed "the highest level of trust" twice as often as the control group. Subjects who were told that they were interacting with a computer showed no such reaction, leading to the conclusion that oxytocin was not merely affecting risk-aversion.[16] Nasally administered oxytocin has also been reported to reduce fear, possibly by inhibiting the amygdala (which is thought to be responsible for fear responses).[17] There is no conclusive evidence for access of oxytocin to the brain through intranasal administration, however.
Affecting generosity by increasing empathy during perspective taking. In a neuroeconomics experiment, intranasal oxytocin increased generosity in the Ultimatum Game by 80% but has no effect in the Dictator Game that measures altruism. Perspective-taking is not required in the Dictator Game, but the researchers in this experimental explicitly induced perspective-taking in the Ultimatum Game by not identifying to participants which role they would be in.[18]
According to some studies in animals, oxytocin inhibits the development of tolerance to various addictive drugs (opiates, cocaine, alcohol) and reduces withdrawal symptoms.[19]
Preparing fetal neurons for delivery. Crossing the placenta, maternal oxytocin reaches the fetal brain and induces a switch in the action of neurotransmitter GABA from excitatory to inhibitory on fetal cortical neurons. This silences the fetal brain for the period of delivery and reduces its vulnerability to hypoxic damage.[20]
Certain learning and memory functions are impaired by centrally administered oxytocin.[10]
The illicit drug MDMA (ecstasy) may increase feelings of love, empathy and connection to others by stimulating oxytocin activity via activation of serotonin 5HT1A receptors, if initial studies in animals apply to humans.[21]

[edit] Drug forms
Synthetic oxytocin is sold as medication under the trade names Pitocin and Syntocinon and also as generic oxytocin. Oxytocin is destroyed in the gastrointestinal tract, and therefore must be administered by injection or as nasal spray. Oxytocin has a half-life of typically about three minutes in the blood. Oxytocin given intravenously does not enter the brain in significant quantities - it is excluded from the brain by the blood-brain barrier. There is no evidence for significant CNS entry of oxytocin by nasal spray. Oxytocin nasal sprays have been used to stimulate breastfeeding but the efficacy of this approach is doubtful[22].

Injected oxytocin analogues are used to induce labour and support labour in case of non-progression of parturition. It has largely replaced ergotamine as the principal agent to increase uterine tone in acute postpartum haemorrhage. Oxytocin is also used in veterinary medicine to facilitate birth and to increase milk production. The tocolytic agent atosiban (Tractocile®) acts as an antagonist of oxytocin receptors; this drug is registered in many countries to suppress premature labour between 24 and 33 weeks of gestation. It has fewer side-effects than drugs previously used for this purpose (ritodrine, salbutamol and terbutaline).

Some have suggested that the trust-inducing property of oxytocin might help those who suffer from social anxieties, while others have noted the potential for abuse with confidence tricks.


[edit] Potential adverse reactions
Oxytocin is relatively safe when used at recommended doses. Potential side effects include:[citation needed]

Central nervous system: Subarachnoid hemorrhage, seizures.
Cardiovascular: Increased heart rate, blood pressure, systemic venous return, cardiac output, and arrhythmias.
Genitourinary: Impaired uterine blood flow, pelvic hematoma, tetanic uterine contractions, uterine rupture, postpartum hemorrhage.

Evolution
Virtually all vertebrates have an oxytocin-like nonapeptide hormone that supports reproductive functions and a vasopressin-like nonapeptide hormone involved in water regulation. The two genes are always located close to each other (less than 15,000 bases apart) on the same chromosome and are transcribed in opposite directions. It is thought that the two genes resulted from a gene duplication event; the ancestral gene is estimated to be about 500 million years old and is found in cyclostomes (modern members of the Agnatha).[10]

Hombre de silicona

Carlos Varela Hombre de silicona

El tipo se pinchó la dosis de silicona,
Sus pechos empezaron a crecer
Soñaba con tener los senos de Madonna,
Soñaba con las piernas de Cher.
Él era hombre, él era hombre,
Pero tenía un corazón de mujer.

Estaba preso dentro de su mismo cuerpo
Sin poder escapar del dolor,
Su sexo que importaba si era falso o cierto
Si ya vivía con la ilusión,
Él era libre, él era libre
Pero soñaba con dejar la prisión.

En el barrio lo miraban de una forma extraña
Por eso apenas se asomaba al balcón.
Sus amantes le decían: la mujer araña,
pero en la calle le gritaban maricón.

Coleccionaba los filmes de Almodóvar
Y las revistas prohibidas por la ley,
Aquella noche todo terminó en su alcoba,
La muerte le beso los labios como un gay.
Él era hombre, él era hombre,
Pero tenía un corazón de mujer.

Es duro vivir así, es duro vivir muriendo
Es duro seguir viviendo, es duro vivir.
Es duro morir así, es duro morir viviendo
Es duro seguir muriendo, es duro morir.

El tipo se pinchó la dosis de silicona,
Sus pechos empezaron a crecer
Soñaba con tener los senos de Madonna,
Soñaba con las piernas de Cher.

Estaba preso dentro de su mismo cuerpo
Sin poder escapas del dolor,
Su sexo que importaba si era falso o cierto
Si ya vivía con la ilusión,
Él era libre, él era libre
Pero soñaba con dejar la prisión.
Paul McHugh Defames Transsexual Women:

In a Catholic magazine article in 2004, Paul McHugh (the Vatican's advisor on sexual matters and an avid J. Michael Bailey supporter) monstrously defamed and ridiculed transsexual women.

In that article, McHugh also claimed credit for 'discovering' that transitioned women are really either "homosexual men" or "mentally-ill sexually paraphilic men", relegating Blanchard's role to that of merely confirming his (McHugh's) "two-type theory". Since that time, major Catholic media have cited McHugh's article in an escalation of trans-bashing by the Catholic hierarchy, as evidenced in the notes further below.

As a member of the Institute of Medicine of the National Academy of Sciences and of G. W. Bush's President's Council on Bioethics, McHugh's credentials have given him clout in elite circles amongst those unaware of his highly-personal hatred of transitioned women (which he masks as "scientific understanding"). It was in these roles that he promoted the publication of J. Michael Bailey's transphobic book.

For more on McHugh's defamation of trans women, see also Andrea James' Webpage about McHugh and Monica Roberts essay "Why Is The Catholic Church Hatin' On Transpeople?"


Contents:
1. Background and commentary on our initial reactions to McHugh's statements.
2. "Surgical Sex", by Paul McHugh,
First Things: The Journal of Religion, Culture and Public Life, November 2004.
3. "Transsexual Truths?", Letter to the editor by Jennifer Usher,
First Things: The Journal of Religion, Culture and Public Life, February 2005
4. Ongoing citations of McHugh's article (as if it were "science") by transphobic religious ideologues.




Commentary on the McHugh article:


In November 2004, psychiatrist Paul McHugh (the Vatican's advisor on sexual matters) came out openly and stated his "scientific" position on "sex changes". The article is full of the usual BBL ideology regarding transsexualism, most of which (as you can see in this article) goes directly all the way back to McHugh and his colleague Jon Meyer at Johns Hopkins in the 1970's. The article is entitled "Surgical Sex", and it can be found at the following Catholic Church website:

http://www.firstthings.com/ftissues/ft0411/articles/mchugh.htm

This article is the latest in a long series of attacks on "sex changes" by McHugh, going all the way back to his personality conflicts and confrontations with John Money at Johns Hopkins in the 70's, with McHugh personally being responsible for closing down the gender clinic there. For more of the historical background on McHugh, see Andrea James' page "Paul McHugh on Transsexualism"

In his recent article, McHugh is ruthless in his caricaturing of transsexual women, which he does in a manner reminiscent of school-yard bullies instead of "famous scientists". In the article he mocks these women and ridicules them in the grossest of ways:

"...The post-surgical subjects struck me as caricatures of women. They wore high heels, copious makeup, and flamboyant clothing; they spoke about how they found themselves able to give vent to their natural inclinations for peace, domesticity, and gentleness—but their large hands, prominent Adam’s apples, and thick facial features were incongruous (and would become more so as they aged)...."

Here we see him making fun of women who, through no fault of their own, had been forced by fate to be masculinized by testosterone, and who had then in many clinics been forced to dress as caricatures of women (in high heels and with lots of makeup) during extended "real life tests" (RLT) as part of the forced-protocol for obtaining access to surgeries.

Furthermore, many of the old clinics forced trans women into RLT without the benefit of hormones, only prescribing hormones after an extended RLT (a practice is still enforced at The Clarke Institute in Canada - now called the CAMH).

McHugh's remarks are thus seen as incredibly offensive - he is seen as ridiculing the very clients that those old clinics forced into the torture of RLT and social transition without the benefit of hormones. And of course McHugh ignores any and all effects of the many modern treatments, including FFS, that can correct the masculinization-effects which McHugh ridicules. Thus he is playing on crude social stereotypes of trans women as "men in dresses", taunting and humiliating them in absentia in the process.



Then, a little further along, we notice a subtle but fascinating claim:

McHugh apparently sees himself as the instigator and principal propagator of the now infamous "two-type" theory of transsexualism. Furthermore, since he apparently believes that he "has won the scientific war against sex changes" by convincing the Vatican to denounce transsexualism in 2000, and by supporting Mr. Bailey's book on the inside at the National Academy of Sciences in 2003-2004, he thinks it is now time to tell the history of his great success!

In telling this story, he reduces the contribution of The Clarke (namely sexologist Ray Blanchard) to that of merely confirming his and Meyer's ideas from the mid-1970's. This greatly reduces Blanchard's "fame" as the "discoverer" of anything, and pushes the two-type theory back to a time in the 70's when psychiatric theories of transsexualism (and homosexuality too) were just prejudices in disguise:


"... Thanks to this research, Dr. Meyer was able to make some sense of the mental disorders that were driving this request for unusual and radical treatment. Most of the cases fell into one of two quite different groups. One group consisted of conflicted and guilt-ridden homosexual men who saw a sex-change as a way to resolve their conflicts over homosexuality by allowing them to behave sexually as females with men. The other group, mostly older men, consisted of heterosexual (and some bisexual) males who found intense sexual arousal in cross-dressing as females. As they had grown older, they had become eager to add more verisimilitude to their costumes and either sought or had suggested to them a surgical transformation that would include breast implants, penile amputation, and pelvic reconstruction to resemble a woman. ... Further study of similar subjects in the psychiatric services of the Clark Institute in Toronto identified these men by the auto-arousal they experienced in imitating sexually seductive females."


These assertions, based on "research" in the 1970's, suggest why Blanchard (and later J. Michael Bailey and Anne Lawrence) also constantly refer to intense, early-onset transsexualism as "extreme effeminate homosexuality", rather than as a form of innate gender feelings in conflict with body sex. These assertions come down to us from a time when homosexuality was openly pathologized by psychiatrists - a time when psychiatrists' knee-jerk reactions were that trans women were simply "gay men".

However, unscientific thought they are, these assertions have been forcefully propagated for over 30 years by this very Paul McHugh, who has been in a position to make them stick in psychiatric circles - even in the face of rapidly mounting and massive counter-evidence against them.

We strongly suspect that when the Bailey book came out, McHugh launched this same kind of tirade against transsexual women inside the National Academies. McHugh is a member of the Institute of Medicine of the National Academy of Sciences and a member of the current President's Council on Bioethics. He would have been the very "top authority" whom the leaders of the Academies turned to to learn about transsexualism. No one there would have realized that McHugh has been on a personal Catholic religious rampage against "sex changes", and has had a closed mind on this entire subject, for the past 30 years.

Is is any wonder then, that the National Academies refused to ever meet with any of the many professional/scientific/academic trans women who wrote and complained when the Academies published the Bailey book? After all, the Academies' elite insider McHugh paints a picture of us as being witchlike creatures, creatures who would frighten any normal person to death if they had to be in the same room with us! Thus is it any wonder the National Academies gave us the silent treatment?

And now, egotist that he is, McHugh is trying to steal Blanchard's thunder by declaring that psychoanalyst Jon Meyer and he (McHugh) were actually the researchers who originated the two-type theory of transsexual mental illness, which we shall from now on call the "Meyer-McHugh theory". According to McHugh, Blanchard merely made some confirming measurements, somewhat in the vein that Bailey "made some confirming observations of transsexuals in Chicago", and then gave a catchy name to one of the types. But in his mind it is really he, McHugh, who figured this all out once and for all, way back in the 1970's.

You will also notice in his article that McHugh also takes credit for causing and sponsoring William Reiner's pioneering work on the cloacal exstrophy cases. By doing this, he moves into a position to "speak for Reiner", and thus more easily misspeak regarding the Reiner's main findings regarding the nature of gender. McHugh even has the nerve to ask regarding trans women,
” Where did they get the idea that our sexual identity (“gender” was the term they preferred) as men or women was in the category of things that could be changed?",
i.e., suggesting that transitioners expect SRS to change their inner identities, when in fact SRS is done to confirm and accommodate to one's existing inner identity. McHugh refuses to believe gendered feelings and gendered identities exist independent of body sex - even though Reiner's work amply demonstrates such independent-of-body-sex inner feeling and identities.

Of course Reiner can openly tell the story regarding his pioneering work on the negative impacts of many intersex infant surgeries without alienating McHugh. He can help bring more wisdom and compassion to the treatment of infant intersex kids, who in the past have been arbitrarily assigned to a gender based on "practical surgical considerations" rather than waiting till they can speak and act for themselves and give their parents some clue as to their inner identities. McHugh loved these results, because they helped him "stop sex changes" (and in the cases of intersex infants, this was usually a correct thing to do).

We wonder though, will Reiner have to wait for McHugh to pass on before telling the overall implications of his results more fully? After all, Reiner's cloacal exstrophy follow-ups are to gender what the moons of Jupiter were to astronomy: The very visible and undeniable reality of something mysterious at the time that had been previously denied (by the Catholic Church). In this case we see stark evidence for gendered feelings and identities that are not based on body sex and upbringing, feelings and identities that emerge strongly during childhood and that cry out for social and physical expression.



William Reiner left Johns Hopkins around a year ago or so, and is now at University of Oklahoma at Oklahoma City. He heads a program in pediatric urology and is doing research there.

But even so, can Reiner really follow-up and talk about those broader implications of his research results? Any such discussions would challenge McHugh's position on gender. McHugh has a powerful stranglehold in elite scientific circles on opinion in that area, and we've seen the power wielded by McHugh against those who dare disagree with him (for example, John Money). Would Reiner dare to openly contradict McHugh's misinterpretations of the cloacal exstrophy results regarding innate gender identity independent of body sex? Only time will tell.

Note that we do see him coming close to this, when talking about intersex kids growing up (it is just a short step to talking about trans kids this way) in the following quotes from a recent article entitled "Living in between, but no longer in silence" (NYU News), by Kim Llerena:

Since the 1950s, surgery has been the preferred method among urologists for dealing with intersex bodies, by "normalizing" genitalia so that children could grow up in a definitive male or female role. Recently, however, new evidence has led some urologists to concede that the genitals do not make the man - or the woman.

"I don't think it matters whether you assign a sex or you don't, or even whether you assign the correct sex," said Dr. William Reiner, a professor in the urology department at the University of Oklahoma Health Sciences Center. "A child is going to identify [himself or herself]. A child's sexual identity can only be known by the child."

In any event, William Reiner is a brilliant scientist and a gentleman and in the end his pioneering work will speak for itself. He will make his mark in scientific history not by the domineering pushing of unsound pet theories as did Money and McHugh, but by doing it the hard way: by doing good science.



Meantime, by prematurely grasping for his place in history, McHugh has now tipped his hand in his essay. He WANTS people to know about his important role in the Vatican decision to denounce transsexualism. He wants people to know about his role in the National Academies' publication and promotion of the Bailey book, a book that the prestigious Southern Poverty Law Center (SPLC) has called "Queer Science". He wants to be "appreciated" for what he considers to be his important scientific efforts to "stop sex changes". However, the publication of this incredibly offensive and overstated Catholic magazine article may prove to be quite a blunder by McHugh:

His irrational and unscientific hatred of transsexual women shows through too clearly, in his gross ridiculing and caricaturing of trans women.

He even has the nerve to comment about how transitioning women talked incessantly about sex in their psychiatric interviews - when it was the interviewer-psychiatrists themselves who would talk about nothing else but sex!

He's also seen, out in the open, overlooking obvious "other interpretations of key data" much like Money did. And, for example, he has totally ignored the evidence of decades-worth of successful transitions by thousands of women.

He then concludes his article by calling gender variance "madness".

McHugh is seen here doing great and tragic harm by making ego-maniacal warped-science pronouncements about transsexual people, just as Money did in his efforts to promote infant genital surgery on intersex kids.



They are two of a kind: Money and McHugh.

Money for decades pushed sex reassignments of intersex infants, under a bogus theory of gender. Money insisted wrongly that gender is socially constructed and that intersex boys could be turned into girls if reassigned surgically early enough. He then deliberately prevented mounting counter-evidence to his theory from being widely revealed to his scientific colleagues. For several decades he pushed and promoted the practice of infant intersex surgeries, even in the face of mounting evidence that his theory was incorrect.

McHugh has for decades tried to stop transsexual sex reassignments, under a bogus theory that trans women are homosexual men or sexual paraphilics. By power of position and personality he stopped (not only the infant genital surgeries, but also) the transsexual surgeries at John's Hopkins. He then deliberately prevented mounting counter-evidence to his theory from being widely revealed to his scientific colleagues. For decades now he has pushed and promoted the idea that "sex changes are wrong", even in the face of mounting evidence that his theory was incorrect - evidence that transsexual transitions can work out extremely well.
In the end, just like Money, McHugh will go down in history as a devil of a man who shattered the lives of tens of thousands of gender variant people. I think we should help him along in this, by making sure his "important role" in history is fully documented and well-remembered.

Lynn Conway
November 26, 2004
Surgical Sex
by Paul McHugh
Copyright (c) 2004 First Things (November 2004).
Their regular response was to show me their patients. Men (and until recently they were all men) with whom I spoke before their surgery would tell me that their bodies and sexual identities were at variance. Those I met after surgery would tell me that the surgery and hormone treatments that had made them “women” had also made them happy and contented. None of these encounters were persuasive, however. The post-surgical subjects struck me as caricatures of women. They wore high heels, copious makeup, and flamboyant clothing; they spoke about how they found themselves able to give vent to their natural inclinations for peace, domesticity, and gentleness — but their large hands, prominent Adam’s apples, and thick facial features were incongruous (and would become more so as they aged). Women psychiatrists whom I sent to talk with them would intuitively see through the disguise and the exaggerated postures. “Gals know gals,” one said to me, “and that’s a guy.”
The subjects before the surgery struck me as even more strange, as they struggled to convince anyone who might influence the decision for their surgery. First, they spent an unusual amount of time thinking and talking about sex and their sexual experiences; their sexual hungers and adventures seemed to preoccupy them. Second, discussion of babies or children provoked little interest from them; indeed, they seemed indifferent to children. But third, and most remarkable, many of these men-who-claimed-to-be-women reported that they found women sexually attractive and that they saw themselves as “lesbians.” When I noted to their champions that their psychological leanings seemed more like those of men than of women, I would get various replies, mostly to the effect that in making such judgments I was drawing on sexual stereotypes.
Until 1975, when I became psychiatrist-in-chief at Johns Hopkins Hospital, I could usually keep my own counsel on these matters. But once I was given authority over all the practices in the psychiatry department I realized that if I were passive I would be tacitly co-opted in encouraging sex-change surgery in the very department that had originally proposed and still defended it. I decided to challenge what I considered to be a misdirection of psychiatry and to demand more information both before and after their operations.
Two issues presented themselves as targets for study. First, I wanted to test the claim that men who had undergone sex-change surgery found resolution for their many general psychological problems. Second (and this was more ambitious), I wanted to see whether male infants with ambiguous genitalia who were being surgically transformed into females and raised as girls did, as the theory (again from Hopkins) claimed, settle easily into the sexual identity that was chosen for them. These claims had generated the opinion in psychiatric circles that one’s “sex” and one’s “gender” were distinct matters, sex being genetically and hormonally determined from conception, while gender was culturally shaped by the actions of family and others during childhood.
The first issue was easier and required only that I encourage the ongoing research of a member of the faculty who was an accomplished student of human sexual behavior. The psychiatrist and psychoanalyst Jon Meyer was already developing a means of following up with adults who received sex-change operations at Hopkins in order to see how much the surgery had helped them. He found that most of the patients he tracked down some years after their surgery were contented with what they had done and that only a few regretted it. But in every other respect, they were little changed in their psychological condition. They had much the same problems with relationships, work, and emotions as before. The hope that they would emerge now from their emotional difficulties to flourish psychologically had not been fulfilled.
We saw the results as demonstrating that just as these men enjoyed cross-dressing as women before the operation so they enjoyed cross-living after it. But they were no better in their psychological integration or any easier to live with. With these facts in hand I concluded that Hopkins was fundamentally cooperating with a mental illness. We psychiatrists, I thought, would do better to concentrate on trying to fix their minds and not their genitalia.
Thanks to this research, Dr. Meyer was able to make some sense of the mental disorders that were driving this request for unusual and radical treatment. Most of the cases fell into one of two quite different groups. One group consisted of conflicted and guilt-ridden homosexual men who saw a sex-change as a way to resolve their conflicts over homosexuality by allowing them to behave sexually as females with men. The other group, mostly older men, consisted of heterosexual (and some bisexual) males who found intense sexual arousal in cross-dressing as females. As they had grown older, they had become eager to add more verisimilitude to their costumes and either sought or had suggested to them a surgical transformation that would include breast implants, penile amputation, and pelvic reconstruction to resemble a woman.
Further study of similar subjects in the psychiatric services of the Clark Institute in Toronto identified these men by the auto-arousal they experienced in imitating sexually seductive females. Many of them imagined that their displays might be sexually arousing to onlookers, especially to females. This idea, a form of “sex in the head” (D. H. Lawrence), was what provoked their first adventure in dressing up in women’s undergarments and had eventually led them toward the surgical option. Because most of them found women to be the objects of their interest they identified themselves to the psychiatrists as lesbians. The name eventually coined in Toronto to describe this form of sexual misdirection was “autogynephilia.” Once again I concluded that to provide a surgical alteration to the body of these unfortunate people was to collaborate with a mental disorder rather than to treat it.
This information and the improved understanding of what we had been doing led us to stop prescribing sex-change operations for adults at Hopkins — much, I’m glad to say, to the relief of several of our plastic surgeons who had previously been commandeered to carry out the procedures. And with this solution to the first issue I could turn to the second — namely, the practice of surgically assigning femaleness to male newborns who at birth had malformed, sexually ambiguous genitalia and severe phallic defects. This practice, more the province of the pediatric department than of my own, was nonetheless of concern to psychiatrists because the opinions generated around these cases helped to form the view that sexual identity was a matter of cultural conditioning rather than something fundamental to the human constitution.
Several conditions, fortunately rare, can lead to the misconstruction of the genito-urinary tract during embryonic life. When such a condition occurs in a male, the easiest form of plastic surgery by far, with a view to correcting the abnormality and gaining a cosmetically satisfactory appearance, is to remove all the male parts, including the testes, and to construct from the tissues available a labial and vaginal configuration. This action provides these malformed babies with female-looking genital anatomy regardless of their genetic sex. Given the claim that the sexual identity of the child would easily follow the genital appearance if backed up by familial and cultural support, the pediatric surgeons took to constructing female-like genitalia for both females with an XX chromosome constitution and males with an XY so as to make them all look like little girls, and they were to be raised as girls by their parents.
All this was done of course with consent of the parents who, distressed by these grievous malformations in their newborns, were persuaded by the pediatric endocrinologists and consulting psychologists to accept transformational surgery for their sons. They were told that their child’s sexual identity (again his “gender”) would simply conform to environmental conditioning. If the parents consistently responded to the child as a girl now that his genital structure resembled a girl’s, he would accept that role without much travail.
This proposal presented the parents with a critical decision. The doctors increased the pressure behind the proposal by noting to the parents that a decision had to be made promptly because a child’s sexual identity settles in by about age two or three. The process of inducing the child into the female role should start immediately, with name, birth certificate, baby paraphernalia, etc. With the surgeons ready and the physicians confident, the parents were faced with an offer difficult to refuse (although, interestingly, a few parents did refuse this advice and decided to let nature take its course).
I thought these professional opinions and the choices being pressed on the parents rested upon anecdotal evidence that was hard to verify and even harder to replicate. Despite the confidence of their advocates, they lacked substantial empirical support. I encouraged one of our resident psychiatrists, William G. Reiner (already interested in the subject because prior to his psychiatric training he had been a pediatric urologist and had witnessed the problem from the other side), to set about doing a systematic follow-up of these children — particularly the males transformed into females in infancy — so as to determine just how sexually integrated they became as adults.
The results here were even more startling than in Meyer’s work. Reiner picked out for intensive study cloacal exstrophy, because it would best test the idea that cultural influence plays the foremost role in producing sexual identity. Cloacal exstrophy is an embryonic misdirection that produces a gross abnormality of pelvic anatomy such that the bladder and the genitalia are badly deformed at birth. The male penis fails to form and the bladder and urinary tract are not separated distinctly from the gastrointestinal tract. But crucial to Reiner’s study is the fact that the embryonic development of these unfortunate males is not hormonally different from that of normal males. They develop within a male-typical prenatal hormonal milieu provided by their Y chromosome and by their normal testicular function. This exposes these growing embryos/fetuses to the male hormone testosterone — just like all males in their mother’s womb.
Although animal research had long since shown that male sexual behavior was directly derived from this exposure to testosterone during embryonic life, this fact did not deter the pediatric practice of surgically treating male infants with this grievous anomaly by castration (amputating their testes and any vestigial male genital structures) and vaginal construction, so that they could be raised as girls. This practice had become almost universal by the mid-1970s. Such cases offered Reiner the best test of the two aspects of the doctrine underlying such treatment: (1) that humans at birth are neutral as to their sexual identity, and (2) that for humans it is the postnatal, cultural, nonhormonal influences, especially those of early childhood, that most influence their ultimate sexual identity. Males with cloacal exstrophy were regularly altered surgically to resemble females, and their parents were instructed to raise them as girls. But would the fact that they had had the full testosterone exposure in utero defeat the attempt to raise them as girls? Answers might become evident with the careful follow-up that Reiner was launching.
Before describing his results, I should note that the doctors proposing this treatment for the males with cloacal exstrophy understood and acknowledged that they were introducing a number of new and severe physical problems for these males. These infants, of course, had no ovaries, and their testes were surgically amputated, which meant that they had to receive exogenous hormones for life. They would also be denied by the same surgery any opportunity for fertility later on. One could not ask the little patient about his willingness to pay this price. These were considered by the physicians advising the parents to be acceptable burdens to bear in order to avoid distress in childhood about malformed genital structures, and it was hoped that they could follow a conflict-free direction in their maturation as girls and women.
Reiner, however, discovered that such re-engineered males were almost never comfortable as females once they became aware of themselves and the world. From the start of their active play life, they behaved spontaneously like boys and were obviously different from their sisters and other girls, enjoying rough-and-tumble games but not dolls and “playing house.” Later on, most of those individuals who learned that they were actually genetic males wished to reconstitute their lives as males (some even asked for surgical reconstruction and male hormone replacement) — and all this despite the earnest efforts by their parents to treat them as girls.
Reiner’s results, reported in the January 22, 2004, issue of the New England Journal of Medicine, are worth recounting. He followed up sixteen genetic males with cloacal exstrophy seen at Hopkins, of whom fourteen underwent neonatal assignment to femaleness socially, legally, and surgically. The other two parents refused the advice of the pediatricians and raised their sons as boys. Eight of the fourteen subjects assigned to be females had since declared themselves to be male. Five were living as females, and one lived with unclear sexual identity. The two raised as males had remained male. All sixteen of these people had interests that were typical of males, such as hunting, ice hockey, karate, and bobsledding. Reiner concluded from this work that the sexual identity followed the genetic constitution. Male-type tendencies (vigorous play, sexual arousal by females, and physical aggressiveness) followed the testosterone-rich intrauterine fetal development of the people he studied, regardless of efforts to socialize them as females after birth.
Having looked at the Reiner and Meyer studies, we in the Johns Hopkins Psychiatry Department eventually concluded that human sexual identity is mostly built into our constitution by the genes we inherit and the embryogenesis we undergo. Male hormones sexualize the brain and the mind. Sexual dysphoria — a sense of disquiet in one’s sexual role — naturally occurs amongst those rare males who are raised as females in an effort to correct an infantile genital structural problem. A seemingly similar disquiet can be socially induced in apparently constitutionally normal males, in association with (and presumably prompted by) serious behavioral aberrations, amongst which are conflicted homosexual orientations and the remarkable male deviation now called autogynephilia.
Quite clearly, then, we psychiatrists should work to discourage those adults who seek surgical sex reassignment. When Hopkins announced that it would stop doing these procedures in adults with sexual dysphoria, many other hospitals followed suit, but some medical centers still carry out this surgery. Thailand has several centers that do the surgery “no questions asked” for anyone with the money to pay for it and the means to travel to Thailand. I am disappointed but not surprised by this, given that some surgeons and medical centers can be persuaded to carry out almost any kind of surgery when pressed by patients with sexual deviations, especially if those patients find a psychiatrist to vouch for them. The most astonishing example is the surgeon in England who is prepared to amputate the legs of patients who claim to find sexual excitement in gazing at and exhibiting stumps of amputated legs. At any rate, we at Hopkins hold that official psychiatry has good evidence to argue against this kind of treatment and should begin to close down the practice everywhere.
For children with birth defects the most rational approach at this moment is to correct promptly any of the major urological defects they face, but to postpone any decision about sexual identity until much later, while raising the child according to its genetic sex. Medical caretakers and parents can strive to make the child aware that aspects of sexual identity will emerge as he or she grows. Settling on what to do about it should await maturation and the child’s appreciation of his or her own identity.
Proper care, including good parenting, means helping the child through the medical and social difficulties presented by the genital anatomy but in the process protecting what tissues can be retained, in particular the gonads. This effort must continue to the point where the child can see the problem of a life role more clearly as a sexually differentiated individual emerges from within. Then as the young person gains a sense of responsibility for the result, he or she can be helped through any surgical constructions that are desired. Genuine informed consent derives only from the person who is going to live with the outcome and cannot rest upon the decisions of others who believe they “know best.”
How are these ideas now being received? I think tolerably well. The “transgender” activists (now often allied with gay liberation movements) still argue that their members are entitled to whatever surgery they want, and they still claim that their sexual dysphoria represents a true conception of their sexual identity. They have made some protests against the diagnosis of autogynephilia as a mechanism to generate demands for sex-change operations, but they have offered little evidence to refute the diagnosis. Psychiatrists are taking better sexual histories from those requesting sex-change and are discovering more examples of this strange male exhibitionist proclivity.
Much of the enthusiasm for the quick-fix approach to birth defects expired when the anecdotal evidence about the much-publicized case of a male twin raised as a girl proved to be bogus. The psychologist in charge hid, by actually misreporting, the news that the boy, despite the efforts of his parents to treat him and raise him as a girl, had constantly challenged their treatment of him, ultimately found out about the deception, and restored himself as a male. Sadly, he carried an additional diagnosis of major depression and ultimately committed suicide.
I think the issue of sex-change for males is no longer one in which much can be said for the other side. But I have learned from the experience that the toughest challenge is trying to gain agreement to seek empirical evidence for opinions about sex and sexual behavior, even when the opinions seem on their face unreasonable. One might expect that those who claim that sexual identity has no biological or physical basis would bring forth more evidence to persuade others. But as I’ve learned, there is a deep prejudice in favor of the idea that nature is totally malleable.
Without any fixed position on what is given in human nature, any manipulation of it can be defended as legitimate. A practice that appears to give people what they want — and what some of them are prepared to clamor for — turns out to be difficult to combat with ordinary professional experience and wisdom. Even controlled trials or careful follow-up studies to ensure that the practice itself is not damaging are often resisted and the results rejected.
I have witnessed a great deal of damage from sex-reassignment. The children transformed from their male constitution into female roles suffered prolonged distress and misery as they sensed their natural attitudes. Their parents usually lived with guilt over their decisions — second-guessing themselves and somewhat ashamed of the fabrication, both surgical and social, they had imposed on their sons. As for the adults who came to us claiming to have discovered their “true” sexual identity and to have heard about sex-change operations, we psychiatrists have been distracted from studying the causes and natures of their mental misdirections by preparing them for surgery and for a life in the other sex. We have wasted scientific and technical resources and damaged our professional credibility by collaborating with madness rather than trying to study, cure, and ultimately prevent it.
Paul McHugh is University Distinguished Service Professor of Psychiatry at Johns Hopkins University.