The Sleeper
(1831)
Edgar Allan Poe
At midnight, in the month of June,
I stand beneath the mystic moon.
An opiate vapour, dewy, dim,
Exhales from out her golden rim,
And, softly dripping, drop by drop,
Upon the quiet mountain top,
Steal drowsily and musically
Into the universal valley.
The rosemary nods upon the grave;
The lily lolls upon the wave;
Wrapping the fog about its breast,
The ruin moulders into rest;
Looking like Lethe, see! the lake
A conscious slumber seems to take,
And would not, for the world, awake.
All beauty sleeps! - and lo! where lies
Irene, with her Destinies!
Oh, lady bright! can it be right-
The window open to the night?
The wanton airs, from the tree-top,
Laughingly through the lattice drop -
The bodiless airs, a wizard rout,
Flit through thy chamber in and out,
And wave the curtain canopy
So fitfully - so fearfully -
Above the closed and fringéd lid
'Neath which thy slumb'ring soul lies hid,
That, o'er the floor and down the wall,
Like ghosts the shadows rise and fall!
Oh, lady dear, hast thou no fear?
Why and what art thou dreaming here?
Sure thou art come o'er far-off seas
A wonder to these garden trees!
Strange is thy pallor! strange thy dress!
Strange, above all, thy length of tress,
And this all solemn silentness!
The lady sleeps! Oh, may her sleep,
Which is enduring, so be deep!
Heaven have her in its sacred keep!
This chamber changed for one more holy,
This bed for one more melancholy,
I pray to God that she may lie
Forever with unopened eye,
While the pale sheeted ghosts go by!
My love, she sleeps! Oh, may her sleep,
As it is lasting, so be deep!
Soft may the worms about her creep!
Far in the forest, dim and old,
For her may some tall vault unfold -
Some vault that oft hath flung its black
And wingéd panels fluttering back,
Triumphant, o'er the crested palls,
Of her grand family funerals -
Some sepulchre, remote, alone,
Against whose portal she hath thrown,
In childhood, many an idle stone -
Some tomb from out whose sounding door
She ne'er shall force an echo more,
Thrilling to think, poor child of sin!
It was the dead who groaned within.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
25 comments:
1) I was wondering what the purpose of how the chapthers opened with a quote from a movie
2) Why were so many different narrative methods used
3) I thought that all of the different narrative methods gave the book a sense of reality
4) The book was interesting although it was not easy to figure out
5) I thought that it was not so much a criminal detective novel as a psychological one
6) I was a little weird how it started off as a detective novel then swithed to examining the different parenting styles of Gladys and Leopoldo
7) What significane does the change in the types of mothers in the beginning and the end hold
8) Why does Puig emphasized sexual fulfillment? Is it possible that this for women could represent emotional wholeness in Puig's eyes?
9) Why does Puig choose the movie clips and actresses he does? Do they in some way say something about Gladys' character?
10) This book at first read is very misleading and baffling. There were certain parts that I had to read over just to get a better understanding.
Jantel Nelson
The Buenos Aires Affair
1. Sexual Repression – How can sexual repression influence the mental abilities of people? How necessary is open sexuality to a person’s wellbeing?
2. Melodrama – The opening of each chapter in the book reflects the irony of the novel as a film scene is used to elaborate on the clichés of Hollywood. How are clichés a reality?
3. Cinema – This is an obvious part of the novel, yet I feel as if much of the novel is told with cinematic descriptions, almost as if the novel where meant to be a play with in a novel, or an aloud description of a film.
4. Ambiguity – There is a way in which ambiguity is really not ambiguous, and it is perhaps more descriptive than the ambiguity itself. This also alludes to a world of fantasy that can only be found in novels where the imagination of the event or meaning of something is in the mind of the reader rather than one the screen for all to see the interpretation of the director.
5. Violence – What is the difference in physical and psychological damage? What is the difference or connection (mostly the connection) to violence committed by individuals and violence committed by groups?
6. Masculinity – Through our culture we see a strong connection between masculinity and violence. It is obvious how society perpetuates this, yet how can this cycle be overcome. How does one separate masculinity and violence, while not de-maculating the man?
7. Desire for Crime- There is something very seducing about the idea of crime. Perhaps this is a result of the connection between violence and masculinity. With a crime there is the idea of reaching the end, of finding out what is the unknown and that desire mimics the same desire of sex.
8. Motivation – Perhaps the word drive which also connects to the ideas of power and sexuality and the power that comes from sexuality and the drive to attain that. There are both physical and mental motivations for the achievement of pleasure.
9. Obscurity of Reality – A similar theme that has occurred through the works of Puig is the difference between the actual past and how we give meaning and interpret the past. What is more real, the actual past or how we remember it? For example, a crime scene is merely a scene of an event that previous occurred.
10. Open and Close – The way in which the novel offers clues yet then retracts and leads us nowhere also mimics the ideas of sexual repression yet also
intercourse itself. There is the idea of hiding yet exposing yourself.
Jessica Wolowski
Here are my comments for the Buenos Aires Affair
1. Leo's sexual identity: Leo's character was not developed apart from his sexuality. I found that I did not really know who he was apart from his sex drives and problems. This really bothered me because I wanted to know what sort of interactions he had in normal situations.
2. Gladys' sexual identity: Although Gladys was a little more developed in terms of discussing her art, she was in a sense bound by her sexual desires and frustrations with Leo. She could not free herself from them. Yet she desires to be fulfilled and expresses this as her goal.
3. Gladys' psychological state: suicidal and what seemed to me to be depressed, her character at the middle and end of the plotline contrasted sharply with the energetic, intelligent, and ambitious girl described in the first few chapters. I think Puig is suggesting that her sexual encounters and "failures" destroy her. She is consumed by it.
4. Similarly, Leo's psychological state and sexual state does lead to his destruction by the end of the novel. His thoughts and fantasies rather than his actions are more important.
5. Detection of characters: The lack of dialogue with Maria Ester Vila keeps the reader from developing an understanding of her apart from Leo's words with her. Similarly, in the first part of the novel, there was a dialogue with a police officer that did not show the text of the responding voice. Here the reader has to act as a detective to piece together what is going on and who is talking. This makes the detective aspect of the novel more introspective than a novel with a typical third person narrator.
6. The character of Maria Ester Vila as an older woman, an artist. She's contrasted with Gladys especially when they were laying on the bed together. I wasn't sure from the text if Leo has sex with her as well? She seems in some ways to be like a mother to Leo which makes that scene even more disturbing.
7. This scene at the end with Leo, Gladys, and MariaEV stresses the tension Leo has with dealing with women of any age. He feels simultaneously helpless and powerful with them.
8. I thought there was a disconnect between Leo and Gladys' childhood development and how they actually ended up together. I can't pinpoint it, but I really don't want to accept that either of them could be so far gone as they were. I think this goes back to my need for further character development to feel like I understand them.
9. Leo's shame over his own sexuality, he calles it "the substance which poisons him" that he has to get out. I'm don't think that he thought sex was poisonous but rather more like he hated that his sexual appetite was insatiable and uncontrollable.
10. Leo was extremely paranoid about being discovered for his rape of a man in his youth not only for its indecency but for its severe violence. He was afraid of being recognized as indecent (as evidenced by the scene with the ice cream cone) as well as dangerous. I think it was this paranoia which drove him and kept him from having normal relations with women. If the paranoia and guilt had been removed, he would have been fine. I think Puig is trying to make this point about the shamefulness of sexual acts and behaviors- that there should be no shame in it. But at the same time the book suggests that the shame is inevitable and unavoidable.
Kate Hansen
1. I found the story hard to follow at first and only got the hang of it after a while.
2. Even though it was confusing at times, I liked the way each chapter started.
3. I think one of the reasons it was hard to follow was because of the different narrative methods.
4. The development and different identities of the main characters is very interesting.
5. I don't think I can name one single type of style for this novel since the detective characteristic and the psychological one was mixed.
6. I like the fact that Puig mixes his love for movies and novel writing in his stories.
7. The issue of sexuality is a main topic in the novel.
8. The constant depression of Gladys was important in that it said a lot about her character and perhaps even foreshadowed some events like the issue of sexual fulfillment.
9. Why can't Leo let go of his past to the point that he feels that part of his life is poisonous him?
10. I started thinking that maybe keeping secrets for Leo wasn't such a good idea in terms of shaping his sexual identity.
a. Novin
I find it interesting that Puig continues to site his love of hollywood by introducing each chapter with a quote or rather a scene from a hollywood movie.
- I like how Puig starts the novel with, in essence, the start of the climax. Then he goes back and explains how the characters got to that point. I also enjoyed how he told the story of Gladys separtely than that of Leo, and then fused them together.
- Puig also shows his unique writing style(s) throughout the text. It is interesting how he switches from strictly third person, to one way conversations (such as Leo's talk with his doctor or his talks with Maria), to actual conversations.
- I found Gladys' mother to be very annoying and controlling both of her daughter and husband. While it seemed that her husband wanted Gladys to pursue her artistic ability, her mother "forced" him to tell Gladys otherwise and in turn she enrolled her in sports (which she did not fit in).
- I like how Puig answered the question to why Gladys stopped working on her art. When she was talking about not wanting to work etc., I was very intruiged on why she did not want to. It is that type of writing that keeps a reader reading.
- One part of the novel that confuses me is the role of the newspaper headings. When the "anonymous" caller has a phone converstation with the officer, he looks at the newspapers (maybe uninterested as first). But then Puig goes on to recall what each headline was about. Why does he do this? The reason escapes me.
- SEX SEX SEX. There can't be enough said about the role of sex in the novel. One of the most fascinating parts of the beginning of the novel is Puig's portrayl of Leo's childhood perversions with his youger sister. With the death of his mother, and his father being absent for the first 7 years of his life, he sisters become the mother. And as he passes through the phallic stages (according to Freud) where a normal child would become jealous of their father and love with their mother, he just falls in love with his sister, the "mother" because the father is absent.
- BEcause of his perverse sexual upbringing, Leo becomes an aggressive, confused sex addict. From choking, to beating, to impotency, his sex life is far from normal and addmitedly the only time he can fully perform is with prostitutes (and even then not every time). This may be a personal comment from Puigs struggle with his own sexuality, although represented by a struggle with impotency (as gay men cannot reproduce either).
- The scene in which Gladys is interviewed while laying next to Leo finally lets the reader inside Gladys' head. While she has struggled for so long to understand herself, it seems she finally has, and in turn the reader can now understand her. Although it is confusing to me how she conducted the entire interview without waking Leo. (side note: before the interview starts, in italics is states "...according to the latter's (Gladys') imagination while resting beside sleeping Leo" ... does that mean that the interview never happened? or that this is how Gladys thought it happened?
- The pychotherapuetic theme runs freely throughout the text. It seems that every character has some emotional struggle and either accepts psychoanalytic help or runs from it. Gladys becomes addicted to pills and Leo gets help from a therapist (and neither work!).
- Also, insomnia seems to be a theme that Puig uses throughout the text, as the main characters, Gladys and Leo, suffer from it terribly. Gladys usually has too many thoughts (many about sex) to sleep, and Leo is burdened with unsatiable erections.
- To follow up on Leo's insatiable erections: it is interesting that a man can become erect seemingly whenever he does not want to, and yet has trouble whenever he SHOULD want to. He can please himself, yet a woman has trouble pleasing him and can only do so when there is a vulnerability about her and when he uses violence.
D. Polster
-Early rejection of Gladys by both parents. From a young age she realizes that her father would like her more if she were pretty, and he later asserts that he doesn't want his daughter to be a dog. Her mother is disappointed that Gladys doesn't recite poetry and is scrawny and unathletic. Gladys ruins her mother's recital by forgetting all her lines and is not the type of daughter her mother desires.
-Later in life Gladys identifies with the "junk" she picks up by the beach to use for her art and refers to it as her "poor fellow creatures who are rejected". She is depressed and feels like an outcast from a very young age.
-The push for psychoanalytic treatment.
-Leo's dream and discussion of butterflies. Their wings seem attractive and alluring at first but then the creature becomes repulsive, he says. This is his relationship with women. Later in the session he discusses the same concept in reference to songs that he originally likes that later become popular. "and it scares me that a beautiful thing can one day become tiring"
-When describing butterflies he also says the butterfly's body is like "a little boy's penis gnawed at". His own sexual innocence was exploited at such a young age-- gnawed away by his older sister. His revulsion of women may stem from his early encounters with his sister. If the penis is a sign of power, and she took part of that away through exploitation, then maybe his tendency towards sexual violence is a way of regaining the sexual control and power that was taken from him at a young age.
-The overlap of arousal and repulsion. Even his encounters with his sister were a mix of the two. While he wanted to be touched, there was an inherent wrongness in the act. It was forbidden and the oldest sister threatened to tell the father if it continued. From then on, Leo's interactions with women often started with arousal and ended in an inability to perform and feelings of intense disgust directed at the woman.
-Overpowering shame and guilt associated with the man he murdered in his youth. He changes the story twice (to his psychoanalyst and to Maria Ester Vila) and says that it was a woman he killed. By the end of the novel, he is so consumed with being caught that it leads to his death.
-Gladys as an underdeveloped women. She was born a premature baby and seemed to lag developmentally for the rest of her life. As an adolescent she was physically less mature than her classmates. As a young artist she was criticized for not branching out in her art and for adhering too closely to past artistic styles. She did not fully cultivate and develop her own talents. Gladys lacks depth. In her imaginary magazine interview she appears superficial and one-dimensional (she talks about perfumes and other beauty products that she wants to buy and shares an overly dramatic and romanticized account of her life with Leo)
-Leo's desire to spend life with his eyes closed as he reveals to his therapist. In a way, Gladys does. Her missing eye and dark glasses allow her to mask herself in a darkness that Leo desires.
-Leo's rage when he feels that Gladys was using him in order to receive his vote for her art exhibition. A man who violently exploits women's bodies cannot handle the thought of being mentally exploited. The idea makes him want to kill.
Christina H
Erica Pakkala
1) Right away my impression of Juan Carlos as being a "player" seemed justifiably so because of his name. I know this piece of literature has no link to the play "Don Juan", but to me it just seemed like there was a link between the names because they are both Juans. I guess Juan Carlos just reminded me of the character from the play.
2)Also, early on I caught that the person writing the letters was most likely not Snr. Etchepare, but I like how the novel doesn't come right out and tell you until the very end. Because it does that, you almost forget that you even suspected that. The line that made me think it was the daughter that hated Nelida is on page 13 and says, "one that that surprised me was your steady handwriting, it seems like a young person's, good for you, and to think that you suffered such a great misfortune lately."
3)Going off point 2, it just seems that Celina is holding a grudge for a absurdly long time. This almost seems to me like her downfall in the book. All she wants is to be liked, yet she sleeps around and in the end n o one really likes her, but because of Nelida's purity, she ends up married and loved in the end. It's almost like Nelida tries too hard, even in the end when she attempts to destroy Nelida, it doens't work and she ends up back with her husband.
4)A thing I really liked about the book were the parts where you would see the same day played out but from several different character's points of view. It definitely helped int he construction of the novel and give you little details to help you guess what was to come.
5) One thing I'm still not sure about are the letters Juan Carlos sent from the boarding house he was in getting treatment for his TB. I know one of them was to Nelida, and the other to his family, but the third I'm not sure about. I was thinking it was to Mabel. But if it was, was he only doing that to kind of "keep her around" in case he ever wanted to hook up with her?
6)Also, along the lines of pint 5, to me it seemed like Juan Carlos really did care for Nelida because he always would hang out with her and wanted to marry her. But at the same time there is a small inkling of doubt in my mind that maybe it was only because he never had any sexual relations with her because she was waiting until marriage and would not allow it with him. So I'm not sure if his intentions were completely pure.
7)A situation I found kind of funny in the book was when Juan Carlos had his fortune read. At first it was very grave and it seemed like the gypsy was really going to tell him his real fortune and we the readers would get to see how it actually took place, yet the fortune suddenly takes a good turn and he ends up getting to marry his true love and die at an old age. Yet, we the reader know that is not true because we find out about his death at the very beginning of the book. Again to me it seems as if the gypsy may have been lying just so that she might get a little bit more money for the fortune, because no one wants to hear they are going to die young or live a terrible life.
8) An interesting subject in here too is that fact that women are usually blamed when sins are committed or irresponsible acts are done. You see this in the 14th episode on pages 197 and 198 when Juan Carlos's mother is talking about the sins he's committed and how she's worried that he might not be in heaven, and that it probably isn't his fault, but "it's the bad women who are to blame..."
9) Another point I wanted to discuss was the fact the even though Nelida doesn't get to live a life with Juan Carlos, she still ends up living a full life with people that care about her deeply. her husband leaves her at first when he finds out about her contact and the letters with the Etchepare family when Celina sends him a letter in the mail. However, Celina's plan fails, and she still ends up alone and Nelida ends up with a loving family (that she may or may not have deeply cared about back) and a loving and devoted husband.
10) The ending of the story I find interesting in the fact that Nelida decides to change her final will. Instead of having the letters so dear to her from Juan Carlos, she ends up telling her husband that she wants them burned instead. I don't know if this is because she finally let go out Juan Carlos and thinks now that she's going to die superficial articles on earth don't matter, or if it's because she has let go of him and is doing this for the peace of mind of her husband.
. The use of varying media/means of narration to tell the story. This seems to be a theme throughout all of the works we have read thus far, and I feel that it enriches the story by giving us different perspectives on the same events.
2. Machismo/masculinity. Throughout the novel, Puig seems to relate being masculine with a penchant for violence. This again is another theme that we have seen in other works.
3. The confusing way in which the novel is organized. I found myself struggling to make sense of the plot throughout most of the novel, but at the same time it seemed to make the story a bit more realistic because in real life we can only go by our own thoughts and experiences, and cannot see daily events through other peoples’ eyes.
4. Sexuality. As is the case with all of Puig’s novels, sexuality is an overriding theme throughout The Buenos Aires Affair. Even from the beginning of the novel, with the description of Leo and his sexual desire for his sister, the issue of sexuality and sexual development is an important theme.
5. The effects of sexual development on other character traits. We can see that Leo’s own sexual development and identity grows throughout the novel and also influences his actions such as the violence that we see him commit later on in the novel.
6. Presence of psychological treatment. This is the first Puig novel that we have read that deals with the issue of seeking help for their psychological problems. It is important to note that two of the main characters (Gladys and Leo) do no have success in trying to treat their psychological ailments.
7. Parental issues. Both Gladys and Leo have them. Namely, Leo does not have a father, and his mother dies when he is very young, leading him to be raised by his sisters. In Gladys’s case, she is rejected by her parents and cannot seem to please her mother or her father due to the inadequacies they perceive in her (her lack of athleticism, not being “beautiful”)
8. Conflict between Gladys’s parents. They seem to fight with each other over control of Gladys. For example, her father wants her to pursue her art, whereas her mother does not want her to (just one example).
9. How the past effects the present and the future. Namely, how Leo seems obsessed with certain parts of his past, which influence his actions.
10. Cinema. Again, we see the presence of film throughout The Buenos Aires Affair, just as we have seen in the prior two novels.
Chris Roxbury
Key Themes of The Buenos Aires Affair
Gladys—Gladys is alone, and in search of both love and success in the art world. Her relationship with Leo is violent. She has mental problems that seems to in part stem from sexual frustration; she often makes friends with older women, and doesn't seem to have much in common with people her own age
Mental breakdown—Gladys is thought to have suffered a mental breakdown in the beginning; many references to mental breakdown made throughout, including to people getting headaches, being ill, and such; Leo also seems to experience breaks where he isn't in control of himself – this may be one of the problems he faces with his impotence
Art –Gladys makes sculpture out of debris from the ocean, Leo is an art critic, Gladys was apparently a talented sculptor from a very young age, but she doesn't pursue it while in America; her ability to make art comes back after she suffers her mental break and comes back to Argentina
Mother-child relationship—Gladys begins the novel staying with her mother; she and her mother do not seem to have a good relationship – her mother seems controlling; Leo's mother is dead, and his father is absent, so the "mother" role in his life is taken over by his sisters, and he seems to develop an incestuous infatuation with, Olga, the younger of the sisters – to some extent this seems to be shared by her
Sex—Gladys has many sexual fantasies, but she comes to sex at a relatively late age, after moving to America, she wants sex, but thinks it's unladylike not to resist, and so Leo is able to have sex with her; Leo is well-endowed, but also basically impotent: he's only able to become aroused when there is resistance. Leo pays for prostitutes, and is willing to have sex with men, but he does eventually try to master his masturbation habits; he may want to overcome his need for sex
Politics—the backdrop to the action in the novel is Argentina's political situation and there are numerous references to this; Leo is involved with anti-government groups for a while, and he ends up being tortured; the politics in Argentina make the situation with Gladys and Leo especially unstable
Leo—Leo is often violent and he seems to become aroused at resistance; he experiments with a man and then kills him; he is well endowed, but unsatisfied in any situation in which his partner is loving towards him – he doesn't seem to want love, and this has basically made him impotent; he seems to be trying to overcome this by not giving into sexual desires such as masturbation; although he is distant, he seems popular with women, and successful at his job
Violence—Leo kills a man while committing a homosexual act, did he do this because he was afraid that he was a homosexual?; Leo seems to like violent sex; he was tortured for his involvement with radical groups; his sisters hit him as a child, as did his father when he saw him, perhaps this is part of Argentine culture
Masculinity—Leo grows up without the influence of his father; he grows up to be impotent and violent, this may be a result of lacking a male influence; his father seems to give Leo conflicting advice: both hitting him and a telling him that some things are okay without women around; Leo is really the only masculine influence over the novel, is he a comment by Puig about Argentine society?
Psychotherapy—numerous characters make reference to getting psychotherapy; although Gladys' friend suggests it, Gladys seems distrusting of psychotherapy; the treatment is often brought up as a possible "cure" to the problems of both Gladys and Leo; many of their acquaintances seem to believe in it power
Thanks,
Anna Cotter
Interesting contrast between the beginning view of Glady’s relationship with the mother, which seems like a caring mother who is just caring for her sickly daughter, and the next section which described Gladys life from her own perspective. From Gladys’ version of the tale, it seems a combination of her father’s equating looks with love (his interactions with her revolving around it), and her mother’s own image obsessed vanity (pretentious to the tee, particularly with the poetry thing), that lead to Glady’s insecurities and tendencies towards depression. Follows Puig’s traditional focus on parental issues resulting in messed up children
- Comparatively, Leo also has problems with an absent father, and a dead mother, but his eldest sister takes the motherly role, and obviously again, faulty parenting.
- Sexuality plays a big role, from Gladys sexual roller coaster which went from zero (her longstanding virginity and fear of losing it) to sixty (with her five big lovers, none of whom were legitimate relationships), to Leo’s sexual maturation through his incestuous love for his sister, which only led to his disturbingly violent sexual desires.
- Leo’s violence in sex also seems to stem from his own guilt over his mothers death, guilt he feels because that’s how his family made him feel, and seemed to feel. It’s interesting that because he was a murderer from birth (technically speaking), he has kept that identity, which is why he is allowed to be a murderer and violent in his adulthood. It also seems to be why to him, his semen is such a terrible thing, why he thinks its so important to release it as little as possible. At one point, he even calls it “the substance that poisons him.” (p.164) It seems to stem from the fact that his father’s semen was what subsequently killed his mother, for it impregnated her with him
- Cleanliness is a big deal to Leo, he needs to get clean of the sin he was born with, so he is never clean, always needs some white soap to clean off his dirty sins of being a murderer.
- The idea of protection seems to be big, relating relationships both sexual and familial (or both, as seems to be the case in the text) to this concept of it being love if provide protection. This was true for Leo by his sisters, true for Gladys about her lovers, BUT while Gladys seems to crave it (and seek it from the worst sources, like Leo), Leo seems to hate the concept because he, being the danger that a person would need protection from, cannot provide it
- They seem to be a masculine and feminine counterparts of this mentally sexual scarring due to their parental rearing. Gladys, being feminine, respond by being more self deprecating and turn to depression, while Leo, the strong male, turned to another form of depression which was using violence. Both affected by this sexually, so that it is difficult to achieve orgasm, both needing large penises to accomplish this (Gladys, her best time was with a large man, Leo, using his large member to inflict pain). Both are best suited to noncommittal relationships, although Gladys doesn’t have the option of prostitutes, and are made by others to resort to psychotherapeutic means “That was my work of art, to bring together scorned objects to share with them a moment of life, or life itself” p. 103. Gladys. They even die in the same manner, differentiate only in the more passive actions that are typically female (jumping off a roof after establishing that she did not have enough pills), and Leo killing himself in a car chase, a much more aggressive way (more masculine)
- No self worth before each other, leads to this need to feel pain, or inflict pain to feel (sexually, and also emotionally), so it works, the sadist found his masochist
- Hair to Gladys seems to be the ultimate sexual sign of a mans virility to her, she seems to love to discuss both the hair easily visible, such as mustache and beard, and that which is not, such describing chest hair, etc. It seems to be her signal that it is a true man, one that would take her to her pleasure.
- Maria’s side of the conversation isn’t shown because it enhance the fact that what she a says doesn’t matter, at least until she starts telling on him to the police. Crazed people like Leo hear what they want. She seems to be to him almost like his sister, Olga, the older woman thing that he must have stemming from his incestuous early feelings for Olga. That is why he wants her to be sure that he wasn’t gay, that the murder he described really was a woman, not a man as it was in reality.
J. Reeves
Maria Kopyta
Buenos Aires Affair Comments
1. Nature of the novel as detective story- less of a criminal, more of a psychological story
2. Motherhood- Connection between mother that is nurturing and one that is sexually satisfied
3. Introductions to the chapters- famous movie lines from movies that present clichés of popular culture, Puig’s continued fascination with the impact on movie and American ideals in Argentina
4. Influence of lack of parent figures on sexuality- Leo’s lack of mother and father figures, his relationship with his sisters, now addicted to sex and with sexual problems- lack of mother?; impotent, violent, frustrations- lack of father figure?
5. Connection between the actresses that present the quotes at beginning of each chapter and Gladys
6. Contrast between Gladys’s sexual fantasies and Leopoldo’s sexual failures
7. Effect of indifferent parenting on child- Gladys’s negative relationship with her parents- What are the different effects that result from abnormal childhood upbringing?
8. Use of different writing methods/styles to intensify reality of novel
9. Sex as a poisonous, i.e. Leo
10. Crime against homosexual- is Leo doing this because if his frustrations with his own sexual “abnormalities”?
Yujie Wang
1. The development of Gladys's sexual psyche. Chapter III, "Principle Events of Gladys's Life" is organized categorically based upon chronological period in her development. It would be interesting to map out Gladys's development of sexual psyche. For example, the shock associated with the first nude man she sees in art class, the double date with her friend, etc. These events serve to shape her, and provide perspective for the analysis of future events.
2. The development of Leo's sexual psyche. Chapter VI, organized as Gladys's life events were organized. Leo's treatment of women (i.e. slapping Susana p. 82, and fantasizing about a "bloody deflowering" of a school girl p. 82) are disturbing, and shed light to his subsequent actions.
3. Applying theories of Sigmund Freud, most notably from his work, "Introductory Lectures on Psychoanalysis" in analyzing character motivation and actions (both Gladys and Leo). This work discusses such theories and ideas as transference, dream / subconscious analysis, and Freudian slips.
4. Repressed sexuality and its destructive implications in both Gladys and Leo. For example, the repressed sexuality of Leo stems from the sexual crime he committed previously. The escape from sexuality in art (or the objectification of sexuality i.e. nude models as objects, and the purposeful disregard of their sexual implications).
5. Leo's lack of personal strength. Shown in his multitudes of sexual frustrations and failures (i.e. multiple episodes of inability to perform), as well as his weak character, as shown on p. 88 - 89 as he became an informant even without being tortured (just punched once), and cried with just imagining the torture (he imagined himself being "sexually crippled"). This fear stems from the crime he committed, in which he not only made a man "sexually crippled," but also killed him. This can be seen as the psychological manifestation of his guilt and paranoia.
6. The purpose of the highly structured format of the novel. Involving categorized information, interview notes, direct dialogs, documents (i.e. CV's). I was not too sure why this format was used. Perhaps Puig is attempting to create a sort of detective's portfolio for the readers, so that the readers are active and function as the detectives. By providing structured evidence and information, this may serve to depict a more realistic detective's case.
7. I thought the sexual problems/intricacies of Leo was a bit too much to be completely believable. Incidence upon incidence of different forms of sex (i.e. talking about it to psychoanalysts, the descriptions in his personal life section, the countless prostitutes he visits, the specific description of sex with Susana every time he goes over to her house is excessive, and I don't find that it is that necessary. Further character development could have substituted those repetitive scenes to shed deeper light into both the characters' psyche, and not just their sexual psyche, but other aspects of their self-identification as well.
8. Comparison of Dostoyevsky's "Crime and Punishment" with "Buenos Aires Affair." Obvious similarities can be seen in the plot, which is the moral anguish that accompanies a crime committed by a character named Rodoin. However, Dostoyevsky wrote his work in mid 1800s, while Puig wrote his in the 20th century. Therefore, certain new theories have been applied since (i.e. psychoanalytic theories of Freud, as mentioned above). A comparison of the methods in which the authors treated this "guilt" (in a loose term) topic would be interesting.
9. Homosexuality. The homosexual crime committed by Leo haunts him for life; however, other 'crimes' that he commits heterosexually do not seem to haunt him as much. Perhaps he is more haunted by the internal acknowledgment of his homosexuality (while externally he rejects it --- physically he is the epitome of an alpha male). Examples: he sleeps with countless prostitutes, basically rapes them (as shown when he forcefully has sex with those who refuse), punches his ex - wife until she draws blood and a tooth comes out, etc. Why don't these heterosexual crimes haunt him as much? What is unique about the "first" crime, besides it being homosexual?
10. The implications of the menage trois: Gladys, Leo, Maria Esther. The psychological, as well as sexual gratification that these three individuals receive. p. 180 the disturbing fixation of Gladys and Maria Esther on Leo's penis. Visually, this creates a triangle, with each individual standing/sitting on each of the corners of the triangle. Leo, erect, faces into the triangle at the corner, and both Gladys and Maria Esther both face Leo. Does Maria Esther represent some form of parental figure for both Gladys and Leo?? An attempt at filling the void. If so, Freud would propose his Oedipus complex ideas to explain the sexual fixation that exists between these characters.
Anupama Prasad
1. Narration: Puig has once again managed to introduce a new and creative method of narration by beginning each chapter with a movie quotation. However, his use of so many different narrative styles made the text somewhat difficult to understand at times.
2. Hollywood Glamour: A Hollywood “it” girl, such as Rita Hayworth or Hedy Lamar, spoke each of the movie quotations that began every chapter.
3. Irony: It is ironic that the subtitle of the novel is “A Detective Novel,” because most of the struggles in the novel were psychosomatic instead of mysterious (most detective novels are enigmatic and puzzling).
4. Sexual Discontent: The novel portrays a woman getting kidnapped and threatened with sexual violation. Gladys, one of the main characters, has numerous sexual fantasies throughout the course of the novel. Leo also experiences sexual troubles.
5. Popular Culture: Puig’s writing seems geared more towards popular culture and not literary technique.
6. Backwards Structure: Puig sort of begins his novel at the climax, or focal point of the whole story. He then explains to the reader how the novel unfolds to that particular point.
7. Family Issues: Gladys has troubles with her parents early on in the novel. This impacts her character throughout the rest of the book.
8. Shame: There is an extreme guilt experienced not only over sexuality, but also over the murder.
9. Overpowering Memories: Both the main characters could not let go of their past memories.
10. Death: There is an undertone of death in the novel. The plot centers on solving a murder mystery. Gladys also deals with suicidal tendencies during the novel.
The troubled nature of the characters: Clara and Gladys (mother and daughter),for example, each suffering from her own quandary- Clara of seeming heartbreak and general dissatisfaction, and Gladys from severe depression
Sexual repression: Gladys! She is "plagued" by her intense corporeal fantasies. I use "plagued" in this context because she is overwhelmed by these desires.
Psychological twist: The plot itself is developed around the study of the character's psychoses. A good example is Leopoldo and how is insecurities translate into sexual violence and dysfunction.
Clichés- the epigraphs that begin each chapter, once more, a tie between Puig's love for Hollywood glamour and drama into his works. Again, there is a reference to Rita Hayworth- the selection of each star was carefully done, his obsessions with Rita still strong, five years after his publication of Betrayed by Rita Hayworth.
Depression and dissatisfaction: Gladys particularly. This theme or aspect of her character really cannot be ignored.
Maternal relationships: Gladys's parents (especially her mother) are very possessive and as such, Gladys does not have a good relationship with them. Leo, on the other hand, has an absent maternal bond because his mother had died. The link here between poor/nonexistent maternal relationships and sexual performance is most interesting. Puig's personal upbringing is not coincidental.
Psychology as treatment – this is very reflective of true Argentine society. Everyone in Argentina has his or her own psychologists and nearly every student studies psychology in the university. Incidentally, Freud is praised in Argentina which is interesting given Freud's thoughts on maternal bond.
The writing style present in The Buenos Aires Affair is very unique to Puig – again, much like a screenplay, uncommon or a novel or a detective novel as it is in this case.
The inseparability between Puig's own life and his work (ie. relationships, desires, etc.) is consistent throughout The Buenos Aires Affair as well as other texts that we have read.
The nature of murder and the degree of violence in The Buenos Aires Affair – Leo's guarded past, his guilt, again with the psychoanalysis of the culture incorporated into Puig's upbringing and writings
Sage Farrar
Ricardo Lopez
1. The novel opens with Glady’s mother Clara Evelia being described. An interesting feature behind Clara is her manner in communicating. At certain intervals Clara substitutes expressing her feelings directly by reciting poems in replacement. This might signify her lack of being able to express her feelings and concentrate on Glady’s.
2. When Glady’s was young she was enrolled in the Leonardo Da Vinci’s Institute. There she fell for a boy and wanted to win the competition, assuming he would too, in order to get to talk to the boy. This symbolizes her innocence in the sexual content and later juxtaposes her many wild sexual encounters, particularly with Leo.
3. Her first real sexual encounter was with a nude model at the Leonardo Da Vinci Institute. This occurred at a young age and depicts how the Argentine culture is not shy about sex. It shows how Glady’s was able to somehow experience a sexual feeling through her art. It also sets up the novel in where the whole book is filled with sexual scenes.
4. When Glady’s returns to New York she first seeks Lon the painter, only to realize he was marries. She later seeks Danny, but he too is taken. This shows Glady’s being vulnerable and needing a man in her life to fulfill her.
5. The method of communicating his message in the novel makes Manuel Puig
infamous in the literary world. In certain chapters, there are dialogues with only one’s person’s responses. This is done purposely, enabling the reader to come up with their own responses and interpretations. Puig doesn’t present the whole picture clear and distinct; rather it’s up to the reader to put the pieces together.
6. In a few of the conversations between Maria Ester and Leo, Leo seems extremely
desperate to meet up with Maria and keep in contact with her. This foreshadows what’s to come in the future. Leo needs Maria in order to go on with his intentions with Glady’s. If Leo is going to murder Glady’s, Leo needs Maria to blame it on.
7. Sex is a major theme in the novel. It seems that at any moment the theme of sex comes in. Even in the most ludicrous and dangerous scenes, sex is still lingering in the background. For example, when Leo goes to see Glady’s at her house, Glady’s recognizes and knows the danger’s; nevertheless, when asked to go into a car, she thinks about the idea of having sex in a car for the first time. She is eventually drugged in the car. The idea of sex clouded her train of thought.
8. In chapter eight, Leo takes Glady’s to a hotel and invites Maria to show up in order to frame her. In the middle of the scene when he is ready to kill Glady’s, Maria persist in exciting Leo, leading to Glady’s being raped. Glady’s feels extreme pain, but at the same time expresses her extreme pleasure. She is fixated with sex and its pleasures.
9. The fact that the reader only gets the story of how Leo and Glady’s first met through the eyes of Glady’s doesn’t fully present a full picture of how Leo felt with Glady’s from the start. This also foreshadows what occurs between them at the end of the book.
10. A big difference between Glady’s and Leo is their first encounter with sex. On one hand, Glady’s was very inexperience at a young age and somewhat gullible & shy to encounter the idea of sex. On the other hand, Leo at a young age had faced the idea of sex. His sister would play the “ant game” with him and he would love it.
1) Importance of the Weather—Descriptions of the sky, the sea, and the weather forecast are important to this novel.
Clouds and rain loom in the distance, meaning bad things are to come. Dark skies and seas are indications of the same
fate.
2) Parallel between mother and daughter—both characters are sensitive, they love the big city, both artsy.
3) A mother’s constant concern for her daughter—her daughter’s mental health state (as one with anxiety problems) also
makes the mother panic and worry, as if they both struggle with the same disorder.
4) Puig continues his theme of social classes into this novel, for example, drawing comparisons between Gladys’ home
and recognition of how she is better off than many of her peers.
5) Gladys sees herself as weak—her perception of her own health is how her health remains.
6) Glady’s preoccupation with money plagues her. She consistently avoids situations where she would have to spend
money. Ex: avoiding going out with male friends who drink a lot and spend money, or is set against seeing a
psychoanalyst because of the bills.
7) Sex/rape—Glady’s rape conditioned her to look a sex and relationships in an unhealthy way. In order to fill the void
left by her assailant, she seeks out sexual relations with a variety of men—many are married.
8) Sexuality—an interesting technique, though I am unsure if Puig himself employs it or if this is new to the translation,
is the footnote-style asterisk of Gladys masturbating. While the world is carrying on around her, the reader is clued into
the secretive nature of her masturbation, and also her anxieties. These actions are removed from the outside, and the
reader gets a personal insight on her reactions to the world.
9) While the outline of Leo’s life is very similar to the structure of Glady’s, one major contrast the reader notes is that his
sexual needs are diminished, relative to most people’s.
10) The final chapter is gives a name to Leo, but uses “the young wife” the entire time. This is a blatant expression of
male dominance in society and within the household. The name “wife” is an object, because you can only be a wife in
relation to your husband—you are your husband’s wife.
Francesca Ferrono
-Masturbation- Both Gladys and Leo are stifled by their inability to not masturbate and are unable to function without sexual satisfaction. It is a predominant theme, as both are crippled by the need to for sexual pleasure constantly.
-Insomnia- Gladys and Leo are unable to sleep when they are missing something in their lives that they have become accustomed to, whether it be a parental figure, a lover or their own personal satisfaction. Everytime there is a void in one of their lives, there s a void in there sleep, signaling the deep loneliness when they are without something that they thought would always be around.
-Inability to be sexually satisfied- Gladys s unble to be satisfied by the majority of her lovers as she moves from one to another trying to find her pleasure-- this is an inverted reference to the inability of these males to be truly masculine as they are unable to please a woman who is looking for that high and displaces their machoness. This reflects onto Leos inability to perform in most situations unless he has an unwilling partner or is masturbating and this lack of masculinity deeply affects him and targets rage to show his machoness
-Rape- Gladys is almost raped and loses an eye, which becomes a signature of her life. Leo is unable to perform unless cruelly raping or simulating rape by becoming violence and pressuring his partner into forced intercourse, with his excitement growing the more resistance he receives. This is juxtaposed against Gladys's inability to be pleased by a man, because as that decreases their machoness Leo is asserting his though the use of force in sexual relations in an indiscriminate manner.
Thanks!
Sincerely,
Jess
Jessica A. Lawless
1. The confusion and anxiety that people sometimes experience when they are growing up, is an important element in The Buenos Aires Affair and Boquitas Pintadas. The humiliation and insecurity that the characters Leo and Gladys experience in their youth, is closely chronicled in The Buenos Aires Affair. Puig describes their thoughts and emotions during times of confusion in a way that defuses through the scenario described and also makes the reader feel uncomfortable.
2. Like Puig himself, the main characters of the The Buenos Aires Affair are artists. Perhaps Puig wrote about artists because he felt he could more accurately and believably depict what was inside artists’ heads than what was in scientists’, politicians’, etc. heads.
3. Cancer is a recurring motif in Puig’s The Buenos Aires Affair and Boquitas Pintadas. Many of the characters (Leopoldo Druscovich, Leo’s wife, Juan Carlos, Nene) die of cancer. It is interesting that the type of cancer that they succumb to is similar: throat cancer, lung cancer (exception is Nene’s spine cancer).
4. Leopoldo and Gladys are haunted by their past, in the form of dreams that occur at night and keep them awake. This may reflect that Puig himself was tormented by memories from his past.
5. Leo doesn’t want to become attached to a woman. This may explain why he does not want to see any individual prostitute more than once.
6. Leo is very self-conscious. This is evident from the fact that he does not want to go to a theater by himself, and from the fact that, when he does go on his own, he enters and leaves the theater under the cover of darkness.
7. Although sex brings Leo great pleasure, it also causes his downfall. After raping and killing the man, and after demonstrating to himself that his sex drive is what controls his decision-making, he becomes much more unsure of himself and self-conscious.
8. The ending of The Buenos Aires Affair is somewhat satisfying to read because it presents some closure for at least one of the characters in the narrative. The older, neurotic mother from the beginning of the books seems to be replaced by a younger, more stable mother.
9. Puig’s style in both the The Buenos Aires Affair and Boquitas Pintadas serves to confuse and surprise the reader at every turn. Puig’s creativity and the skill with which he puts together the jigsaw puzzle of events in his narrative are unique and very impressive.
B. Traa
1.) In Godard’s film, Contempt, a quote from film theorist Andre Bazin is spoken with the written opening credits, “The cinema substitutes for our gaze a world more in harmony with our desires.” Puig inverts this mechanism, he writes, where there should be expository fiction, transcriptions of lines spoken in films. How is this related to Godard’s utilization of Bazin’s quote? What of the content in Bazin’s quote pertains to Puig’s vision of amalgamated fiction?
2.) Transgression in the act of perverse eroticism. Poe’s narrators sought transgression through excess, specifically, transgression through excess perversion. How is this applicable to Leo?
3.) Unconscious vs. Conscious both in theoretical and literal application. Pervasive in various digressions of cognition pertaining to therapy, specifically concerning the reoccurring discussion of the validity of a psychoanalytic approach to therapy, as well as the practical application of analysis and creation of art.
4.) Bataille’s protagonist in The Blue of Noon explains that he “enjoys being an object which causes horror and repugnance” in the being he is sexually involved with. Leo seems to demonstrate a similar mentality in that he cannot sustain erection unless the individual he is coupling with struggles against, insults, or demonstrates repulsion to him. Why is this?
5.) Silence is utilized in both Blanchot’s novels as well as Godard’s films. How is the utility of silence in Godard’s dystopia or Blanchot’s totalitarian state used differently than in Puig’s omitted transcriptions of fact? Particularly concerning the police hand-written citation of the “anonymous” phone call?
6.) Puig was obviously a proponent of the cinematic and a believer in the amalgamation of forms for transcendental expressionism, Ms. Levine said he was going to direct but died before he got around to it, but why the hell didn’t he incorporate visual aspects into his work as the authors of the visual-text pieces “Hiroshima Mon Amour” and “La Jetee “did?
7.) In Blue of Noon Bataille’s protagonist says, “Beauty is desired in order that it may be befouled; not for its own sake, but for the joy brought by the certainty of profaning it.” I find this extremely applicable to Leo, especially in his insomniatic vision of the rotting dog licking his gentles. How else does Leo find ways to befoul beauty?
8.) Because love is a sort of death lived, in advanced with a knowable end found in the orgasm accompanying erotic acts, and because death seems always incomplete or unfinished (it continues infinitely after one man’s death, is unknown, and unreal), love escapes or alludes death by putting an end to death by making a momentarily real end of it (specifically in the orgasm- “little death”). How does this pertain to Gladys’ sensation of God and heaven upon orgasm? Of the other characters’ visions upon orgasm?
9.) What are the implications of the headlines considered contemporary to the unfolding events of the novel? What’s the significance of this mechanism? Explaining a part of each story, but only the primary portion is certainly indicative of the beginning of detective’s work (Puig deems this novel a “detective” story).
10.) Leiris explains that a ceremony is sacred only if there is an immediate risk of life in its actions. The bullfight is ceremonially sacred because the matador risks his life. During the bullfight the divine or sacred is present as the matador perpetually evades death capturing “a rapture in whose depths horror and pleasure coincide.” This is a significant explanation of Leo’s violent desire in the erotic. Leo especially cannot be fulfilled via masturbation because there is no risk of pleasure and horror coinciding.
Trisha Calvarese
Liz Romanow
Ten bullet points: General topics for discussion (One pertaining to an earlier class)
1. BEAUTY AND TRUTH (KEATS): In the film, in the scene in the classroom, the teacher alludes to a particular poem, “Ode to a Grecian Urn”, and “Ode to a Nightingale” by Keats. The former is a poem which reflects on the tension between beauty, life, and truth on the one hand, and mortality and death on the other. The poet speaks of life as it is immortalized on the urn, but there is also a sense of the morality and fleeting character of all life that underlies the immortal beauty he finds on the urn. (This contrast was also the theme of Keats’s “Ode to a Nightingale”.) I wonder how Keats figures into The Last Picture Show, and perhaps also Puig’s Boquitas pintadas? Could trivial affairs and relationships between the characters be unimportant, at least in the grand scheme of things, while ideals of real beauty remain present in both texts, albeit in different forms? Also, what to make of the fact that in Puig, this conception of beauty is associated with pop culture, film, and the media?
2. CHARACTER COMPARISON & THE PURSUIT OF LOVE. Gladys Hebe D'Onofrio, in her thirties, is depressed, suicidal, yet deeply inspired and creative. She has loads of sexual fantasies, always dreaming of an ideal lover. She is our heroine, if we can call her that. Versus Nené, from Boquitas pintadas, who sends letter declaring her love for the dead Juan Carlos Etchepare. In what ways do the characters compare? Who is more heroic? Why? And, perhaps the real question here, is the pursuit of an ideal love constitutive of a form of heroism? What are the criteria for heroism? Do the novel and the film have a position on this?
3. THE ME, MYSELF. According to Suzanne Jill Levine, “The novel [referring to The Buenos Aires Affair] was where he most successfully integrated self and society” (296). This makes me think back to Crane, and how he uses his poems, especially “The White Buildings,” to tell about himself. He held that the written corpus was the image of the
real poet, to use Whitman’s terms, the “Me Myself,” even though Crane had
plenty of biographical information discussing otherwise. Can we say that the
“real Puig” is in his novels?
4. FINANCIAL AND SEXUAL SUCCESS. Gladys Hebe D'Onofrio has rich
sexual fantasies, and is depressed and suicidal. Leopoldo Druscovich, the art critic, is successful, but with repeated sexual failures. Is there an inverse relationship here between personal (financial or otherwise) success and sexual pleasure? And one related to, and intimately connected to, gender? Are all financially successful people doomed to boredom in the bedroom?
5. ART AS AMALGAMATION: Gladys has a unique perspective on art:
That night I felt lonelier than ever. Imprisoned by
despair I returned to the cottage and, almost crazed, I had an inspiration.
I couldn't sleep. At five the dawn found me on the beach, for the first time
picking up the debris that the surf had left on the sand. Flotsam, I only
dared to love flotsam, anything else was too much to dare hope for. I
returned home and began to talk--in a whisper so as not to wake up
mama — with a discarded slipper, with a bathing cap in shreds, with a torn
piece of newspaper, and I started to touch them and to listen to their
voices. That was my work of art, to bring together scorned objects to share with them a moment of life, or life itself. That was my work (emphasis mine).
Note when she says, “To bring scorned objects to share with them a moment of life, or life itself.” Gladys believes in a type of art that brings together, or collages, disparate objects; in what ways does this conception of art speak to the art of the novel, and more generally, modern art? In what ways is it similar?
6. IMAGINATION AS INSPIRATION. Gladys is able to cope with her sense of the oppressiveness of reality by creating fantasies; in other words, using her imagination. This reminds me of how imagination figures in El beso de la mujer araña, where memories of films stimulate Valentín to use his imagination creatively, and allow him to affirm that it is possible to love, and therefore, to have courage, even in the face of torture. It also enables Valentín to overcome one of his greatest fears, the fear of betrayal of his political commitment by someone he loves. With Gladys, at the moment she tries to commit suicide, when she is at an all time low in her life, she too uses her imagination. (She has a fantasy of a young couple and child, who were living in the apartment next door.)
7. DOUBLE TROUBLE: FAMILY AS FICTION AND REALITY. There are two discussions of the family. In the first description, we have Gladys’s fantasy. The
second is the more “real version” in each partner is aiming for perfect sex. Which family is more real? What can be said about the juxtaposition of two separate facades of what it means to be “family”?
8. GLADYS AS PHALLUS SYMBOL? (First, note the distinction between the phallus and the penis: the former refers to a cult object in the shape of a penis, or representational of a penis, whereas the latter is the real thing.) Is Gladys the “heroine” of the novel? Is she morally weak or strong? She is filled with fantasies, and deeply creative. Yet she is insecure and possibly a weak character. However, she seems to resurrect herself each time. Can the “resurrection” be figured as a “re-erection,” suggesting the phallus as a symbol of life? What can be said then about how her resurrecting, or re-erecting capabilities occur again and again?
9. PUIG A LA DERRIDA. I want to talk about Puig’s narrative structure, the
way it is confused and perplex, and how meaning is achieved amid this structure. Consider the way in which Derrida posits that there is a type of necessary “spacing” between the written text on the page, and the reader himself? And what does this have to do with the complicated narrative structure of the novel?
10. FOOTNOTES GONE WILD. Gladys’s sexual pleasure is revealed to us in the
footnotes: “Gladys sitent que el orgasmo se aproxima”, “Gladys siente que el
orgasmo se resiste a comenar” (65), etc. What are the potential clinical implications here? Can you see it functioning in an ironic or humorous way? What can be said about putting this information in the footnotes? What ways does this contrast/compare with other works by Puig, like for example El beso de la mujer areña?
11. PUIG, A “WHITMANIAN FIGURE” FOR MARGINAL ARGENTINA? Whitman can be thought of as a representation of America, the American dream, democracy,
brotherhood, etc. — basically, all that America was before industrialization took place. I wonder, can we say that Puig has the status of a Whitmanian figure, a figure who is both representative and marginal, for Argentinian society? (Whitman was both representative and marginal, marginal in the sense that he was gay and representative in the sense that he figures as a type of America, but one which is ultimately in tension with the contemporary pressures associated with modernization). Can we link him to other writers, like Whitman and even Crane, who were both gay and isolated because of their sexuality?
Liz Romanow
Ten bullet points: General topics for discussion (One pertaining to an earlier class)
1. BEAUTY AND TRUTH (KEATS): In the film, in the scene in the classroom, the teacher alludes to a particular poem, “Ode to a Grecian Urn”, and “Ode to a Nightingale” by Keats. The former is a poem which reflects on the tension between beauty, life, and truth on the one hand, and mortality and death on the other. The poet speaks of life as it is immortalized on the urn, but there is also a sense of the morality and fleeting character of all life that underlies the immortal beauty he finds on the urn. (This contrast was also the theme of Keats’s “Ode to a Nightingale”.) I wonder how Keats figures into The Last Picture Show, and perhaps also Puig’s Boquitas pintadas? Could trivial affairs and relationships between the characters be unimportant, at least in the grand scheme of things, while ideals of real beauty remain present in both texts, albeit in different forms? Also, what to make of the fact that in Puig, this conception of beauty is associated with pop culture, film, and the media?
2. CHARACTER COMPARISON & THE PURSUIT OF LOVE. Gladys Hebe D'Onofrio, in her thirties, is depressed, suicidal, yet deeply inspired and creative. She has loads of sexual fantasies, always dreaming of an ideal lover. She is our heroine, if we can call her that. Versus Nené, from Boquitas pintadas, who sends letter declaring her love for the dead Juan Carlos Etchepare. In what ways do the characters compare? Who is more heroic? Why? And, perhaps the real question here, is the pursuit of an ideal love constitutive of a form of heroism? What are the criteria for heroism? Do the novel and the film have a position on this?
3. THE ME, MYSELF. According to Suzanne Jill Levine, “The novel [referring to The Buenos Aires Affair] was where he most successfully integrated self and society” (296). This makes me think back to Crane, and how he uses his poems, especially “The White Buildings,” to tell about himself. He held that the written corpus was the image of the
real poet, to use Whitman’s terms, the “Me Myself,” even though Crane had
plenty of biographical information discussing otherwise. Can we say that the
“real Puig” is in his novels?
4. FINANCIAL AND SEXUAL SUCCESS. Gladys Hebe D'Onofrio has rich
sexual fantasies, and is depressed and suicidal. Leopoldo Druscovich, the art critic, is successful, but with repeated sexual failures. Is there an inverse relationship here between personal (financial or otherwise) success and sexual pleasure? And one related to, and intimately connected to, gender? Are all financially successful people doomed to boredom in the bedroom?
5. ART AS AMALGAMATION: Gladys has a unique perspective on art:
That night I felt lonelier than ever. Imprisoned by
despair I returned to the cottage and, almost crazed, I had an inspiration.
I couldn't sleep. At five the dawn found me on the beach, for the first time
picking up the debris that the surf had left on the sand. Flotsam, I only
dared to love flotsam, anything else was too much to dare hope for. I
returned home and began to talk--in a whisper so as not to wake up
mama — with a discarded slipper, with a bathing cap in shreds, with a torn
piece of newspaper, and I started to touch them and to listen to their
voices. That was my work of art, to bring together scorned objects to share with them a moment of life, or life itself. That was my work (emphasis mine).
Note when she says, “To bring scorned objects to share with them a moment of life, or life itself.” Gladys believes in a type of art that brings together, or collages, disparate objects; in what ways does this conception of art speak to the art of the novel, and more generally, modern art? In what ways is it similar?
6. IMAGINATION AS INSPIRATION. Gladys is able to cope with her sense of the oppressiveness of reality by creating fantasies; in other words, using her imagination. This reminds me of how imagination figures in El beso de la mujer araña, where memories of films stimulate Valentín to use his imagination creatively, and allow him to affirm that it is possible to love, and therefore, to have courage, even in the face of torture. It also enables Valentín to overcome one of his greatest fears, the fear of betrayal of his political commitment by someone he loves. With Gladys, at the moment she tries to commit suicide, when she is at an all time low in her life, she too uses her imagination. (She has a fantasy of a young couple and child, who were living in the apartment next door.)
7. DOUBLE TROUBLE: FAMILY AS FICTION AND REALITY. There are two discussions of the family. In the first description, we have Gladys’s fantasy. The
second is the more “real version” in each partner is aiming for perfect sex. Which family is more real? What can be said about the juxtaposition of two separate facades of what it means to be “family”?
8. GLADYS AS PHALLUS SYMBOL? (First, note the distinction between the phallus and the penis: the former refers to a cult object in the shape of a penis, or representational of a penis, whereas the latter is the real thing.) Is Gladys the “heroine” of the novel? Is she morally weak or strong? She is filled with fantasies, and deeply creative. Yet she is insecure and possibly a weak character. However, she seems to resurrect herself each time. Can the “resurrection” be figured as a “re-erection,” suggesting the phallus as a symbol of life? What can be said then about how her resurrecting, or re-erecting capabilities occur again and again?
9. PUIG A LA DERRIDA. I want to talk about Puig’s narrative structure, the
way it is confused and perplex, and how meaning is achieved amid this structure. Consider the way in which Derrida posits that there is a type of necessary “spacing” between the written text on the page, and the reader himself? And what does this have to do with the complicated narrative structure of the novel?
10. FOOTNOTES GONE WILD. Gladys’s sexual pleasure is revealed to us in the
footnotes: “Gladys sitent que el orgasmo se aproxima”, “Gladys siente que el
orgasmo se resiste a comenar” (65), etc. What are the potential clinical implications here? Can you see it functioning in an ironic or humorous way? What can be said about putting this information in the footnotes? What ways does this contrast/compare with other works by Puig, like for example El beso de la mujer areña?
11. PUIG, A “WHITMANIAN FIGURE” FOR MARGINAL ARGENTINA? Whitman can be thought of as a representation of America, the American dream, democracy,
brotherhood, etc. — basically, all that America was before industrialization took place. I wonder, can we say that Puig has the status of a Whitmanian figure, a figure who is both representative and marginal, for Argentinian society? (Whitman was both representative and marginal, marginal in the sense that he was gay and representative in the sense that he figures as a type of America, but one which is ultimately in tension with the contemporary pressures associated with modernization). Can we link him to other writers, like Whitman and even Crane, who were both gay and isolated because of their sexuality?
1)Why are all chapter oopenings quotes from a movie? Is it just Puig's way of maintaing his link to the movies, commonly found in his other works
2) I found the relationship between Gladys and Leo and how they somehow seem to be interconnect and feeding off of each others and somewhat dependent on each other.
3) Each chapter seems like a min-short story, since the styles are so different from chapter to chapter
4) There seems to be some underlying masochism and sadism between the characters throughout the novel
5) Sexual Repression - it seems ad if the inability to express oneself sexually is link to this abnormal mentality.
6) The character of Leo was always linked to sex and sexuality. It seems as if his sexual activities and identity are the only bits of information about Leo the reader is provided with.
7) It seems like Leo suffers from Ego-dystonic homosexuality, because he is quite disturbed and confused my his sexual orientation and has gone to say that it is the substance that has posions him.
8) Could both Gladys and Leo suffer from sexsomnia? Gladys was unable to sleep because of her sexual desire and somewhat obsession with sex. While, Leo is unable to sleep because of his uncontrolable erections. Research has shown that such things as high levels of sexual thoughts and sleep-related erections are common among the those diagnosed with sexsomina.
9) Death is always present throughout the novel from the on going plot of murder to Gladys and her thoughs of suicide.
10) Freud would have loved this book and had a blast analyzing all these indviduals
A. Maldonado
Kayla Culver
4/09/08
The Buenos Aires Affair
1. I find it hard to believe that Gladys’s mother chose not to inform the police when her daughter mysteriously goes missing, just in case it was a false alarm. I would expect mothers to naturally act with the opposite logic immediately run to the police when their child may be in danger.
2. Neither Gladys nor Leo had successful parents (by successful, I don’t mean wealthy, I mean successful at being good parents when it comes to raising and nurturing their children). This may have caused their psychosis and odd behavior later in life.
3. Gladys often associated flames with genitals. She always wanted to touch or grab fire and sometimes thought about it while masturbating and she talked about trying to hold burning logs or catch sparks when (in her imagination) describing her relationship with Leo to a magazine. She fantasizes about it.
4. Why did both Gladys and Leo only feel more comfortable building friendships with and opening up to older people? Unlike with other women, Leo actually talks to María Esther and even confesses what he did to the young blond man so many years ago. Gladys never seemed comfortable around her friends in high school, but quickly befriended a woman in her 30’s when studying in America.
5. The relationship Leo had with his sister, Olga, when he was young probably contributed his bizarre sexual desires.
6. Gladys is masochistic. She enjoyed being kidnapped, tied up, and raped by Leo. I think her suicidal thoughts are attributed to the fact that she takes so much pleasure in pain rather than the fact that she is actually depressed.
7. Leo is very sadistic. He can only enjoy sex if his partner resists him or is in pain. If he/she enjoys it, he is unable to perform and becomes disgusted by him or her. This is part of the reason why he never wanted or was able to have a long relationship.
8. I don’t understand why Leo thought it would help to have María Esther “stop him” from killing Gladys. Was it to convince her that he had attempted to kill a woman in the vacant lot years ago, instead of a young man?
9. There were a few examples of associating sexuality with animals. For example when Leo was thinking about a dog with scabies licking a naked man.
10. The enormous size of Leo’s penis is sort of a main theme in the novel. This also attributes to his sadistic and bizarre sexuality. Always showing it off as a child and teenager lead to his hyper sexuality. He enjoys that fact that he hurts anyone that he penetrates.
1) I found it interesting that in the first chapter when Clara was reciting the lines of poetry that she couldn't remember what followed the lines, except that it was something bad. Why I thought that was interesting is because usually people like to block out the bad things, and it also gave me a sense that something bad was going to happen, and as you know her daughter ends up missing from her bed.
2)A line that confused me was when Clara was describing Gladys' sleep, she said it was deep and a good sign of recovery, yet "felt on her back two strong wings ready to unfold." That quote there sounds to me like something angelic, like she was dying and not recovering.
3) I noticed very quickly that this book is very similar to "Heartbreak Tango" in the fact that it has little clips in the beginning of each chapter. I'm not sure what they mean or why they are relevant, but it seems the Puig likes to put them there.
4) I think the descriptions in the novel are very good.They get you in the tone and into the scene very well, like you're almost really there.
5) I really liked the little dialog at the beginning of each chapter. I thought they were clever, but always very sexual. However I didn't really see their overall relevance to the rest of the chapter or story.
6) I found it very odd that Clara (a married woman) was planning on writing a piece entitled "How Melancholy Are Brides" just some time after she got married.
7)I find the relationship between the daughter and her parents sad. It seems like the mother cares too much because she wants so much for her daughter, but yet the father almost seems apathetic because his attitude seems like he doesn't care and tell her to always "listen to her mother."
8) I thought it was odd that Clara was so excited to do the portrait drawing of a naked person, but then when the guy came in, she instead became frightened of a muscular well built man. most people would find that very attractive.
9) After the three important "sexual episodes" that Gladys goes through I got the sense that she was a lesbian because she never expressed any interest in men at all and seemed to be horrified by them or just disinterested.
10) I really liked how the chapters seemed to flip back and forth. It was as if some chapters were more psychological than others. You could tell because the description was very intense and precise. It's almost like you were inside the person's head.
E. Pakala
Elizabeth Heenan
Puig, just as in Heatbreak Tango, starts his novels in media res, but in the middle of the future climactic recollections/realizations. The first part of the book has an informational newsy tone and seemingly objective narrator, and later Puig continues with the gathered documents and perspectives like in Heartbreak Tango…
1.) Why does Gladys’s family seem to feel some sort of inexplicable hatred for her? Granted she is socially unambitious and later made less attractive from her attack (or adding an air of mystery and romance?), but she is smart, gifted, and artistically inclined. Gladys’s aunts and grandmother were HAPPY when the neighbor that Gladys so enjoyed moved away because they were jealous of the comfort she felt there. That is the opposite of love. Are they all just terrible people, or is there something unsettling/off/wrong with Gladys that makes them feel this way. Is it related to the sorrow present in her family when she came into the world?
2.) Gladys is purposefully anti-social and picks fringe, unstable individuals to befriend- Is this because of her nature as an introverted artist or nurturing (or lack thereof) by her clearly toxic parents? The people she spends her time with are clearly illustrated as under achievers, unaccomplished, and conflicted themselves…
3.) When she sleeps with the young impeccably dressed young man, she feels something thawing, “an ice cube between her ribs creating tears” CHECK QUOTE then “drained and incapable of reacting.” This is confusing because it seems to simultaneously talk about a heart becoming warm, and a body becoming immobile. Are these details used to show that she is confused sexually at this time in her life or am I misinterpreting one description/both?
4.) The documentation of Glady’s masturbation is strange, and obviously connected to an amalgam of thoughts about past lovers, yet strange things seem to turn her on, rather than physical characteristics or emotional memories, fried food on a street corner is what causes her to unconsciously start again. A “stream of consciousness” description of writing I feel is overused in academia, but it’s the best way to describe the straight text, paragraph breaks neglected, in which the asterisks describing Gladys’s actions are scattered throughout.
5.) Artistic egotism is very present throughout, starting with Clara’s and Gladys’s reciting of poetry together, pushed upon Gladys by her mother, who delivers with consummate professionalism and continues with Galdys’ drawing of Viven Leigh, only because she was “the only actress with as much prestige as Ingrid Bergman,” (pg. 23) Later, the young man who scorns Gladys because of her win in the sculpture contest
6.) “You have to pay attention to Mommy, because Daddy doesn’t want to have a dog for a daughter,”- This stings Gladys and she can hear it coming. How can a father say this to his daughter? This clearly will have something to do with her relationship with men- maybe an unconscious quest to NOT be a dog, or perhaps a constant idea that she is one…
Post a Comment