Thursday, March 13, 2008

Did Manuel Puig know about preeclampsia?

Dear Professor Gonzalez,

Thank you for lending me your book, it has really helped me prepare my presentation for my other class, behavioral biology seminar. You will find it next to your door. Below are my thoughts on the chapter of preeclampsia, as well as that of the girl who wrote on the margins (while she was who I thought she was, I agreed with many of her sentiments, as you shall see below). Since I can’t be at class because of my flight home (which even as is cost over $500 so I could not change it try as I might because it would have cost another $400), I wanted to give you my thoughts and summary of that chapter, which was absolutely unbelievable to me. Have a fantastic break,

Jessica Reeves
Summary
Basically, preeclampsia occurs as a consequence of the trophoblast being unable to properly complete the second phase of implantation (in the uterus), which is the stage which is supposed to lead to increased blood flow to the placenta by modifying the spiral arteries. Without this transpiring properly, the fetus later on shall receive inadequate nutrition from the mother
- Their thesis is that “this second phase of implantation in humans also may have evolved to enable females to unwittingly terminate pregnancies that were not in their long-term reproductive interests.” (192) What problem with this paper is that the researchers are seeking to state that. Humans need the 2nd implantation for their big brains, but also takes out human choice about who they choose to reproduce with, basically seeking to say that prenatal infant mortality happens when the guy should not be reproducing.


Girls notes:
p.192:
literally: pointing to where the author says guided by evolutionary perspective, the girl writes “which also holds that female infidelity happens for the same reason- maximizes the reproductive benefit. So…put “fetal,” “developmental” evolutionary” before every 3rd word in a crappy psychology book and have evolutionary psychology”
What she is angry about is that the researchers are using onlypart of a theory that while it is a legitimate theory, it should be used as an extremely loose original guide that for the most part is overridden by common human choice, a theory that is very masogenistic [sic. misogynist], and I personally believe should not be used to base a research theory for humans on. Beyond which, their theory that “preeclampsia is a biological mechanism that evolved to terminate maternal investment under circumstances in which the likelihood of investment by the sire is doubtful,” aka that the baby’s father isn’t going to stick around, is ridiculous and again, it takes away human choice in reproducing, and just a major step backwards in feminist movement.

p. 195: After a lengthy discussion by the researchers on how semen becomes familiar, with the pinnacle being that swallowing during oral sex lead to the woman’s body becoming “familiar” with semen, the girl writes “why don’t you bottle it and sell it as multi-vitamens” because it is absolutely ridiculous the things they are trying to justify under this “research”. Basically, reduces human procreation to just repetition of semen intake, rather than joining of two people.

My thoughts:
-It is saying that the reason people are able to have babies together is if they have sex together several times, so that the woman feels safe he won’t leave her, because without the man, the woman is destined for the most part for failure (ridiculous), rather than it just being our choice to have sex with a man whether or not he is a regular partner.
-Also, don’t like the implication that woman shouldn’t have sex with many men because it will cause them to have more instances of fetal death, because it is putting the blame on the woman for not having just one partner, it is a return to old days of thinking how women should not be loose, and releasing males from blame “Length of cohabitation prior to conception … risk factor,”

-p.196-197 next to the paragraph which discusses the serious cost (in terms of energy, resources, etc,) childbirth had for women, the girl wrote the note “a very costly opportunity.” I’m not sure what she meant by that, but for me, I feel like this paragraph, as well as the next couple, where they talk about the evolution of humans as if they were not people, but rather just another species, and about rape from an extremely clinical and cold manner. They say that rape is bad because “it is highly unlikely the child’s father will care for the mother and her infant...reduced chance of attracting committed mates I the future.” They say that is why it is in the woman’s body’s best interest to abort the fetus. The fact that they can talk about rape, like that, not talking of the emotional trauma, and in fact potentially furthering a woman’s trauma by trying to put scientific reasoning why children of rape are mistakes, or nature’s slipups, and it is neither right,
nor justifiable scientifically speaking because the evolutionary perspective leaves a lot of factors out of play. They overemphasis its influence in our actions, like where they discuss that female college students were less likely to go out alone, to a dimly lit area, etc, during their ovulatory phase of menstrual cycle saying it is because our innate wiring warns us that it could potentially lead to us getting pregnant if we were to be raped. However, they conveniently decide to ignore the fact that an important factor affecting this tendancy, if it is true, is that during the ovulation stage of the menstrual cycle, some women tend to experience a mild amount of pain, and that some experience some mid-cycle bleeding. Both those would be serious factors in why the woman might choose to stay home more than she would if she were feeling normal. If I wasn’t feeling well, I’d stay home too, and it would have nothing to do with me thinking that maybe I’m going to get raped, and that might lead to me getting pregnant.

-pg. 197, the “authors write about the three situations leading to unfamiliar semen: Rape, artificial insemination (so they are seemingly giving a scientific stance against it to by tying it in with rape, ridiculous), and lastly, a girl who has sex too early in the relationship (again, rather controversial in its impacts). The girl wrote the note “that there wasn’t too much sex before the relationship consolidated as much never crossed their mind,” and I think this is a rather sarcastic quip by her, or rather it would be fore me, because although they are talking about anthropologic means by which this spontaneous abortion came about evolutionarily, but they are using more modern ideologies, like courtship, which is ridiculous.

-p. 198: the authors begin a series of biological reasons about pregnancy and how a successful one comes about, but in reality, they make no actual connection as to how it is that “familiar” semen would cause these chemical reactions to go about. The girl who took notes in the book wrote “But this is pure biology, so only insignificant importance to the evolutionary psychology a illustrationĂ  or worse: chemistry (yuk!)” I agree with her, both in the dislike of chemistry, and the fact that this purely biological argument where they use a bunch of information as too specific biological reactions actually do nothing to define things in terms of their argument which is based on evolutionary predictions/ why that would affect those reactions. It really hurts their argument that they would try to use such big words to throw someone off the scent that they have no actual scientific backing or reasoning to their theory.

-p. 198-199 under Other pregnancy complications the girl writes “This concoction is disgrace to both evolutionary studies of psychology not to __ a the evolutionary psychology still hope is out there.” While even I could not determine all the words this girl wrote, I agree with the general sentiment. These authors are using evolutionary studies in a manner to promote things that are unfathomable, and trying to take one back to the age old theories of how single or unmarried mothers are an affront to nature, and from that, god. People are people because they have their own choices, and hence consequences, without saying that our decisions are punished if they go against this so called theory.

-At end of p. 197, girl writes “which goes for all kinds of depression group, but don’t let this stop you”. She also writes, “so it takes an evolutionary psychologist (or two) to discover that infanticide occurs when the mothers do not want the children” She writes this because finally, in this very tiny portion of the study paper, the authors admit to psychological factors in child birth and death, but given the lack of emphasis this is given in the study, I totally agree with her sarcasm.

No comments: